4 ms·
> The DMCA (section 117) allows creation of archival copies from the original media that you legally own. It does not allow you to obtain a copy from another en
by sneak 8y ago
> The DMCA (section 117) allows creation of archival copies from the original media that you legally own.
It does not allow you to obtain a copy from another entity, either by archiving theirs, downloading it from a torrent, or whatever other means. The copyright they had can't be transferred to your copy.
Sequences of bits are fungible. If you have a license to possess the work, you have a license to possess the work.
(disclaimer: I am not a lawyer.)
- jahewson 8y agoThere’s no such thing as a license to possess a work. Your license is to possess a copy of the work and you can back-up that copy. But you have no license to make a fresh copy of the work from elsewhere. While the bits may be fungible, their origin is not - and that is what matters.
- chrischen 8y agoYes but the DMCA section mentioned explicitly allows you to make copies for archive (or even for resale!), if you own the right to a copy already. "legal media that you already own" is not mentioned anywhere in that DMCA section.
- exolymph 8y agoClassic post on the provenance of files being important for legal reasons: http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23 http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23