4 ms·
Here's a quote from this excellent article: > An error rate of even one percent will still mean tens of millions of acts of arbitrary censorship, every day. A
by westurner 8y ago
Here's a quote from this excellent article:
> An error rate of even one percent will still mean tens of millions of acts of arbitrary censorship, every day.
And a redundant -- positively defiant -- link and page title:
"Today, Europe Lost The Internet. Now, We Fight Back."
https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2018/09/today-europe-lost-internet-now-we-fight-back https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2018/09/today-europe-lost-inte...
Firms with 50 or less employees should stay that small, really.
VPN providers in North and South America FTW.
- chimeracoder 8y ago> VPN providers in North and South America FTW. Article 13 will affect the entire Internet, not just people in Europe. Most people on the Internet use large, multinational platforms. Those platforms will set rules according to the lowest common denominator, because it's the easiest to implement. This means that people all over the world are going to have a much more difficult time with any user-generated content. That's true even for user-created content, even if there is no other copyright holder involved (look at how badly Content ID has played out).
- irrational 8y agoOr they just stop doing business in Europe.
- hutzlibu 8y agoSince europe is a quite big market, maybe not an option and easier to geolocate and restrict just EU-Traffic
- trothamel 8y agoOr just not, if there's no nexus to europe. I suspect for a small business, the right thing to do would be to simply ignore EU directives. I would not be surprised if the US passes a law to make judgements against US companies without a European nexus (users in Europe would not count) unenforceable in the US. That was done with the SPEECH act to stop libel tourism.
- snaky 8y agoThat's not quite 'one global world' we were told about a decade ago.
- craftyguy 8y agoYea, well we were promised flying cars by now too.
- snaky 8y ago> Communism in 20 years was a slogan put forth by Nikita Khrushchev at the 22nd Congress of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union in 1961. > In his speech, Khrushchev promised that communism will be built "in the main" by 1980. His phrase "The current generation of Soviet people will live under communism" was the final phrase of the new Program of the CPSU adopted at the congress. > The latter political slogan is attributed to Kremlin speechwriter Elizar Kuskov, who allegedly quipped "this slogan will survive centuries".
- irrational 8y agoI'm still waiting for my hoverboard.
- westurner 8y agoTechnically, the phrase "Useful Arts and Sciences" in the Copyright Clause of the US Constitution applies to just that; the definitions of which have coincidentally changed over the years. The harms to Freedom of Speech -- i.e. impossible 99% accuracy in content filtering still results in far too much censorship -- so significantly outweigh the benefits for a limited number of special interests intending to thwart inferior American information services which also currently host "art" and content pertaining to the "useful arts"; that it's hard to believe this new policy will have it's intended effects. Haven't there been multiple studies which show that free marketing from e.g. content piracy -- people who experience and recommended said goods at $0 -- is actually a net positive for the large corporate entertainment industry? That, unimpeded, content spreads like the common cold through word of mouth; resulting in greater number of artful impressions.
- paulddraper 8y ago50 is a magic number in the U.S. as well. The Affordable Care Act and Family Medical Leave Act both kick in at 50.
- andmarios 8y agoThis is not entirely accurate. One thing that doesn't seem to get much publicity, is that this law also fixes the broken DMCA process. Platforms are expected not only to avoid taking down the wrong content, but they are obligated to have stuff (not computers) that rapidly examine any complaints about unlawful take-downs and re-instate the content. http://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/press-room/20180906IPR12103/parliament-adopts-its-position-on-digital-copyright-rules http://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/press-room/20180906IPR...
- x3n0ph3n3 8y agoYou call that a "fix"? Sounds like a windfall for incumbent media companies.
- colechristensen 8y agoA "fix" for DMCA is small civil penalties for obviously invalid takedown requests. Small ones. $1 to the carrier and $1 to the content poster and $1 to the bureaucracy. Enough to push back on the automated takedown shotgun and make inaccuracy expensive. Little risk to some dude defending his garage band's IP because he's going to be careful, lots of risk to big content's robot army.
- mcv 8y agoThat link certainly seems to tell a completely different story. It's good that there are exceptions for small platforms, wikipedia and github. That doesn't change the fact that the upload filter in particular is something that even Google can't seem to get right, so it's highly questionable what they really expect from this.
- andmarios 8y agoI guess what I hope about, is that right now the DMCA doesn't provide a good incentive to tackle wrong take-downs. Maybe by making this into a law, the process can get better. Companies will always do the absolute minimum required —and as a shareholder, this would be what I would demand as well. So it's up to us to set this minimum to an acceptable level. Of course, I understand there are many ways this could go wrong. Law most of the time plays catch-up...
- lxe 8y agoA "quote" you say? That'll be $100.
- jimnotgym 8y ago> Europe lost the internet. That is a bit much, it is not close to becoming a regulation yet. True, the EU Parliament could have stopped this regulation. However now it moves on to the national governments to be argued over.
- isostatic 8y agoAnd there's me thinking the EU wasn't democratic. Not only can elected MEPs stop it, but so can the each member government (or at least enough of them).
- em3rgent0rdr 8y agoDemocracy isn't that great if the people vote for politicians who implement bad laws. What I'm afraid of is that the majority of Europeans actually think this law is good.
- Blaiz0r 8y agoI see no evidence of that, not including ill-informed politicians
- ionised 8y agoEuropean here. Anecdotally, I don't know anyone personally who thinks this is a good thing. I do however know many that are in great approval of GDPR (as I am).
- dagw 8y agoAnother European here. Anecdotally, I don't know anyone personally who's actually paid any amount of attention to the details of this.
- tutanchamun 8y agoI'm really curious what the german government will do. As far as I know they (CDU and SPD) have a paragraph about being against upload filters in their coalition agreement. Interestingly the one who spearheaded article 11 and 13 - Axel Voss - is a german CDU politician. Preach water and drink wine?