2 ms·
I don't think the link tax will have any real implications. Any individual party that starts charging for links will simply not be liked to. It would only work
by wongarsu 8y ago
I don't think the link tax will have any real implications. Any individual party that starts charging for links will simply not be liked to. It would only work if an entire industry/sector would start charging for links to them, but then we are talking about collusion and price-fixing which is already illegal. It's hard to start demanding money for something that was free and costs you nothing.
And the link tax has excemptions for plain hyperlinks and the like, which prevents most distopian uses of such a provision.
If google acts on this it will be because they know this was written with them in mind and if nothing happens stricter laws will follow. But for everyone else it will be a non-issue.
Upload filters on the other hand are a much bigger problem, mostly because copyright law is way to strict to make them reasonable.
- interhero 8y agoHow do you find who is charging and who is not? Why not the other way around - if you post a link, you give exposure - that's worth something no?
- jonathanstrange 8y agoEvery sufficiently large publishing company on earth will demand a link tax, where "sufficiently large" means they can afford one or two lawyers. Why shouldn't they? It's money lost otherwise.
- wongarsu 8y ago>Why shouldn't they? Say BBC decides they don't need the money and doesn't charge for links, but every other major outlet does. Now everyone will just link to BBC when they want to link an article on the topic, and Google News would essentially be BBC and a bunch of small independent outlets. Shortly thereafter the market share of all major news outlets that aren't BBC plumets as less and less people visit their online presences.
- sjwright 8y ago> It's money lost otherwise. It's a choice between more money or less money, but the opposite way around to what you're implying—because nobody will pay for the privilege of gifting traffic to someone else. If you're a web publisher and you're not making more money as your traffic increases, you're doing it wrong. And if you can only make money by taxing all potential inbound sources of traffic, you'll quickly find yourself with no traffic—and no money.