3 ms·
We should just revoke drivers licenses for people who can't operate cars responsibly. It's way too easy to get a license and keep one in the US today. We don'
by mulmen 8y ago
We should just revoke drivers licenses for people who can't operate cars responsibly. It's way too easy to get a license and keep one in the US today. We don't even re-test.
- Someone1234 8y agoOutside of the East and West coasts and other high density cities, it is difficult to revoke licenses simply because there's no infrastructure in place as an alternative to driving. Large parts of the US today there's no public transport, and even no sidewalks(!) in some places. You could ride a bike, but that requires physicality and drivers aren't exactly bike-friendly. If there was a realistic alternative to driving, you might see it become easier to revoke a driver's license, but until then, it just isn't viable.
- mulmen 8y agoAgreed that it can’t work everywhere but 80% of Americans live in cities so there are significant populations that don’t need cars.
- zanny 8y agoEasy to say from the position of thinking you can't lose your license or have the financial means to deal with such a loss. For a majority of those living in the US the places they live and work have been so fundamentally designed around cars that no alternative form of transit is usable. Busses might run once a day, no sidewalks, no bike lanes amidst 5 layer highways. Even getting out of ones housing development via anything but a car can be challenging if its a fenced in community with winding lane and a half roads parked full of cars. I'd naturally much prefer more strict licensing and more frequent license revocation - if for no other reason than it would demonstrably save many lives - but only after we solve the car sprawl hellscape that is a majority of settled US territory.
- dionidium 8y ago> Easy to say from the position of thinking you can't lose your license or have the financial means to deal with such a loss. There's a villainous cycle at work here. Car supremacy produces cities in which you need a car, so that attempts to push back on car supremacy can be credibly opposed on the grounds that they hurt the poor and less advantaged, when of course the very opposite thing is true.
- setr 8y agothe opposite is true in the long run. In the finalized scenario, where public transport is cheap, functional, useful and maintainable, or modern cities have been totally rewritten to support pedestrian first, it makes more sense than cars. But between removing cars today, and the day public transport actually reaches such a state, is long and far, and you fuck the car-less over for the entire duration. You can't suddenly make getting a license harder without also changing a hundred other things too, if you have any intent to preserve any other lifestyle than one that does not require a car, or is not at risk of losing their license. Such a claim is indeed a self-centered one, if you aren't also arguing for the other things as well, simultaneously. To suggest it without the even referring to the rest alongside it is to create the image of horror, to anyone who isn't already aligned with your premise. And if you weren't intending that statement for people who didn't already agree with you, then the most you could have accomplished was virtue signaling, and I don't know why you would want to do such a horrible thing
- rootusrootus 8y agoTo be fair, the OP didn't suggest taking away cars from poor people, just from people who can't be bothered to learn to drive responsibly.
- setr 8y agoIf you take cars away from every group equally, then the poor are the least capable of finding an alternative (because they usually cost). In fact, if you take anything from the entire population in equal measure, its bound to affect the poor the most (because they’re the least capable of finding alternatives to the status quo). So in any such argument, they’d naturally become the front of the topic. If anyone is going to get fucked by a broad policy, it’s the poor.
- mulmen 8y ago80% of Americans live in cities. It’s entirely possible to reduce our reliance on individual car ownership.
- closeparen 8y agoWhere “city” means “not rural.” The vast majority of those are in seas of sparsely packed single family homes separated from the nearest businesses by miles of busy roads, not walkable/urban/transit connected cores. Consider the Bay Area, population 7 million, with closer to 1 million of those in SF and Oakland. Then consider that the Sunset and Richmond, also basically suburbs, make up a huge chunk of SF’s land.
- TheGRS 8y agoI get that sentiment, but man would that be an easy thing to abuse systemically. Having a car is very essential to life for most Americans.
- mulmen 8y agoI’m not convinced. 80% of Americans live in cities. Certainly some of them do truly need cars but there must be some significant population that can get by without them. For a sample size of one I don’t actually need one myself.
- TheGRS 8y agoI don't typically need one myself, but I'm a software dev who lives close enough to downtown bike into work or take a 20 minute bus ride. But this is a huge exception to what the rest of my life was like. If I lived in the burbs it would be very difficult to manage without a car. I have to imagine a significant portion of the 80% you cited lives in the suburbs and are 30-60 minutes away from their jobs and 15-30 minutes away from grocery stores.
- swebs 8y agoI doubt people would use their phones during the test.
- mulmen 8y agoThen why have driver training at all? As it stands a person could drive for 60 years without ever being instructed in changing rules of the road. This is independent of someone driving their car irresponsibly which should be punished more severely.