3 ms·
> When you have something that is enforcing a social contract, that is government. Only if the enforcement is coercive. Otherwise the term "government" is mean
by pdonis 8y ago
> When you have something that is enforcing a social contract, that is government.
Only if the enforcement is coercive. Otherwise the term "government" is meaningless, since every social interaction can be viewed as some kind of "enforcement" of some "social contract". Enforcement by the voluntary choices of other people not to associate with you if you do things they don't like is not government.
> So, if someone in one of those villages murdered someone else, nothing would happen?
Not at all. Instead of concocting straw men, you should go read Friedman's treatment of saga period Iceland.
> I never said my argument is "we can't get there from here".
Fine. Other people have made that kind of argument, so I'll just respond to them on it from now on.
- bena 8y agoNo, coercion is not a requirement for government. That's another definition you're trying to overload. Also, what happens if I don't agree with a rule. And then I break it? If there is some sort of punishment, then there is coercion. Fear of punishment is a coercive device. Then what happens. Tell us that. "Nuh uh" is not a coherent defense. The period of Iceland mentioned in that book was a federation headed by a monarchy. That's a government.
- pdonis 8y ago> coercion is not a requirement for government Then you and I are defining the word "government" differently. What I am arguing against is coercive enforcement of rules. You can call it whatever you want; if you don't want to call it "government", then let's just avoid using that word at all so we at least know what we're talking about. > what happens if I don't agree with a rule. And then I break it? If there is some sort of punishment, then there is coercion Then, once again, you are giving different meanings to words than I am. "Coercion" as I am using the term means forcing people to do things they would not voluntarily choose to do. Letting people voluntarily choose to do something, in the full knowledge that they will suffer consequences, and then imposing those consequences, is not coercion. Also, you use the word "punishment", but I haven't used that word. I have not talked about throwing people in jail. I have only talked about things like refusing to interact with someone. Unless you are going to claim that you have a right to have other people interact with you, no matter how much of an asshole you are, then I don't see how you can call it "coercion" when people refuse to interact with you because you refuse to regulate your behavior in order to facilitate cooperation. Violent consequences are a more complicated matter, yes, but (as is discussed, for example, in Friedman's book) there is still a key difference between violent consequences from private entities (who have to weigh the possibility that they will in turn be targeted by violent consequences from other private entities) and violent consequences from governments (which do not suffer any consequences in turn, because they are allowed to do things that would be considered crimes, at least on their face, if private entities did them--in fact, this is how Friedman defines a government).
- pdonis 8y ago> Then what happens. Tell us that. As I've already said, that's way too complicated for an HN comment. Which is why I've referred, multiple times now, to a book-length treatment of the subject.