5 ms·
Xyz company is not your friend. Ok, like we didn’t know they are trying to make money off the other side? When is the last time a company trying to make a profi
by m3kw9 8y ago
Xyz company is not your friend. Ok, like we didn’t know they are trying to make money off the other side? When is the last time a company trying to make a profit is our friend?
- beaconstudios 8y agoany time where they are trying to make a profit by selling you something you want?
- etatoby 8y agoBingo. Why are so many people willing to throw away the baby (capitalism) with the dirty bathwater (monopolies and others crony deviations.)
- 2bitmachine 8y agoBecause Capitalism historically always evolves into monopolies and crony deviations? Along the way it also typically subverts and destroys democracy.
- HarryHirsch 8y agoOne answer would be that with improved communication and improved transportation the relative advantage of monopolies has become intolerably large.
- na85 8y agoTo use your analogy, it's not clear to me that one can have the baby without it spoiling the bathwater.
- beaconstudios 8y agoyou don't think people exchanging goods and services using money as an intermediate exchange (aka capitalism) can be a net-positive? Because any other aspect of our current formation of capitalism is negotiable. We can regulate to counteract negative corporate behaviours (though that has its own set of issues) so that companies are working for the benefit of the populace.
- wongarsu 8y agoI don't think money is a nessesary ingredient of captialism (though it is immensely helpful). Money also exists in most forms of communism. Capitalism is more about private ownership of the means of productions, with different companies competing against each other on the market. Monopolies run against the spirit of capitalism. Regulated markets on the other hand are fine as long as competition is ensured.
- beaconstudios 8y ago> Capitalism is more about private ownership of the means of productions That existed before capitalism - in feudalism, for example. It's true in the context of Marxist analysis of capitalism as that's how Marx decided to frame capitalism, but it isn't capitalism's distinguishing feature. > Monopolies run against the spirit of capitalism. Effectively, yes, which is why we should prevent them by either public ownership of natural monopoly resources (public road ownership, for an example to wind up the libertarians) or regulation.
- bildung 8y ago> you don't think people exchanging goods and services using money as an intermediate exchange (aka capitalism) That isn't capitalism, you just described a market. Markets existed for thousands of years before capitalism was created.
- beaconstudios 8y agoYeah I know, but my point was that the market plus money is the indivisible unit of capitalism. You can take any other aspect away and it will still be capitalism. Unless you think some other fundamental characteristic is also required? I'm open to that idea. Private ownership of the means of production isn't really one because that existed during early market economies too.
- bildung 8y agoYes, private ownership is one condition, but not the only one. I'd add capital intensive production (building plants and machinery for automation), the existance of a labor market and the existance of a big class of people lacking ownership of the means of production, thereby being forced to sell their labor on the market. And you have a class of people living off of the profits generated by the means of production (in contrast to feudalism, where people also lived without working, but the means came from fiefs, not from the market).
- mindcrime 8y agoExactly. As Adam Smith said: It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own interest.
- dsr_ 8y agoAnd if you don't regulate them in the interests of the people at large, they will conspire to advance their own interests. The free markets need regulation, or they stop being free.
- mindcrime 8y agoEverybody "conspires to advance their own interests"... that's pretty much the definition of self-interest. Anyway, the point is just that one doesn't expect companies to be your friend. You expect them to pursue their own interest, and thankfully their interest and your interest overlap quite often - and mutual, voluntary exchange of goods, service, and currency occurs. Are there things I wish Amazon, for example, did differently? Of course. And the wonderful thing about the free market is that if enough of their customers become unhappy about some issue or other, another company can come along and serve those customers. Of course that might not happen, and that's fine. Nobody is claiming that a free market guarantees that everybody gets exactly what they want.
- projektir 8y ago> Everybody "conspires to advance their own interests"... that's pretty much the definition of self-interest. There are very different forms of self-interest, the one implied here is of the very shallow, short term kind.
- wolco 8y agoYou think your interests overlap. They have been carefully presented this way to extract maximum value from you over the long term.
- 8y ago
- tyu100 8y agoWe are in a historical paradise for consumers of selection and low prices, I think we are doing alright. If Amazon doesn't deliver (pun intended) we will go somewhere else. There is no shortage of competition in the retail space.
- astura 8y agoCompanies like Costco and Wegmans are known for being socially responsible, so it's possible. Both have a strong and loyal customer base.
- larkeith 8y agoThis viewpoint fails to consider the nontrivial competitive advantage gained by building customer loyalty. There are plenty of brands that do well despite higher prices, longer waits, etc due to their consistent positive interactions with customers; A culture of trust between customer and company is frequently worth the cost. Amazon seems to have decided that the higher margins of counterfeits and prioritizing ads over search quality are worth the loss of user trust. I wholeheartedly hope this will be a costly miscalculation on their part, as I would prefer a marketplace with fewer ads and reliably genuine items.
- linuxftw 8y agoI agree with you. Amazon's questionable inventory tactics have been a factor for me in deciding to sometimes shop elsewhere. Although, I don't mind the ads, they're selling screen space, I can happily scroll past them, the adds are often very relevant, and they are clearly marked sponsored.