3 ms·
If the math works out so well then why don't elevators and other apparatus that lift things with electric motors use batteries and regenerative braking on the w
by dsfyu404ed 8y ago
If the math works out so well then why don't elevators and other apparatus that lift things with electric motors use batteries and regenerative braking on the way back down in order to mostly offset the energy cost of operating them?
I'm betting the economics of recovering gravitational potential energy don't really work out in most use cases.
- mikeash 8y agoBased on a quick search, it looks like regenerative braking for elevators is available, albeit not universal. There's also a big difference between doing it in an elevator, which operates intermittently, can't be scheduled to match grid supply and demand, and works with relatively light loads, and doing it with a dedicated system that can match the grid and use much heavier loads.
- 2sk21 8y agoAnd of course regenerative braking is very commonly used in railroads. This works for both AC and DC fed systems.
- srigi 8y agoElevators are not cranes. There is always a counterweight, so "dropping" empty cabin is not generating energy. During that time you're lifting counterweight.
- RobertRoberts 8y agoWouldn't the counterweight only balance (a guess) an empty elevator? Therefore any added weight would be useful for energy recapture? I realize there may be some over compensation in play, but unless the counter weight's weight is actual adjusted for each load, there should be something to work with.
- andechs 8y agoCounterweights are typically 40% of the a loaded elevator car weight, minimizing the overall work that needs to be done to lift any given car, while also limiting the maximum power required to lift a full car.
- bunderbunder 8y agoRegenerative elevators do exist. I've no idea what they cost, but, shooting from the hip, I'm guessing they aren't worth the added price on any but the biggest buildings. Any weight difference due to meatsacks in the elevator will be relatively small compared to what a drum full of concrete weights. Going off the math in TFA, and assuming your average meatsack weighs 75kg, lifting one of them 15 meters up (so, roughly, to the top floor of a 6 story building) stores about half a smartphone battery worth of potential energy. So you probably want to be lifting them much more than 15 meters - and be packing your elevator cars full of them - if you want to pay off the cost of the fancy regenerative kit in any reasonable amount of time.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]