4 ms·
How on earth did this troll post get 17 votes? There's only one paragraph in it that's even new, and that doesn't say anything that hasn't already been said.
by pg 19y ago
How on earth did this troll post get 17 votes? There's only one paragraph in it that's even new, and that doesn't say anything that hasn't already been said.
- paul 19y agoI'm starting to get the feeling that there's a big jealousy factor developing here. The formula is simple: find something that's getting traction and getting talked about, and then bash it. This bashing is very appealing to people whose own efforts are less successful (or more likely have never started), because it reassures them that the other people's efforts and success aren't "real" or legitimate. The same thing can be seen in the comments on TechCrunch (along with the jealousy of failed competitors).
- ashu 19y agoI think the "never have started" is probably the crux of the matter. People who don't actually build things tend to look at the world from a very different perspective. The focus is more on "how is this thing different from anything else I have seen" and not on "is this thing actually useful to a non-trivial set of people out there". When they focus on the first part, it is very easy to bash almost all things out there. Google? That's just search. Gmail? That's just webmail. IPhone? Just a smartphone - doesn't even have 3G and GPS!
- nostrademons 19y agoI think it's more a distinction between "people who have problems" and "people who don't have problems". When you don't have a problem, you're in browse mode - open to new ideas, but only if they're substantially different from everything you've ever seen and trigger some flicker of recognition, some reason to think it's a good idea. When you do have a problem, you're actively looking for something to solve it, and get really excited about the solution. So if you happen to have the particular problem that Xobni solves, it's great, but if you don't, it's just ho-hum.
- ph0rque 19y agoTo confirm your explanation, I never could understand the appeal of jottit until I attended a meeting where I was able to put up a site of what was being discussed before the end of the meeting using jottit.
- jdroid 19y agoIt's lame to pretend the reactions of potential clients aren't important. Even if there is a jealousy factor, a good founder would take it into account and act accordingly. "But isn't xobni just an outlook plugin?" Clearly people have that idea in their head. Now what is xobni going to do about it?
- brlewis 19y agohttp://www.xobni.com/ http://www.xobni.com/ "Drowning in Email? Find Email & Attachments Instantly" "Xobni is the Outlook plug-in that helps you organize your flooded inbox" It looks to me like they're focused on reaching people who have a problem to solve, and aren't concerned about being viewed as "just an outlook plugin."
- nostrademons 19y agoMany of the people who're objecting - at least on these TechCrunch and FeedBurner stories - would never have bought it anyway. It's better to concentrate on the folks who will buy it (I assume they're out there, though I'm not one of them...) and make something that they'll use, love, and tell people about. http://weblog.raganwald.com/2007/01/what-ive-learned-from-sales-part-i.html http://weblog.raganwald.com/2007/01/what-ive-learned-from-sa...
- brlewis 19y agoI do see that happening with friendfeed. It must be hard sometimes to find useful feedback when there's all this noise from random bashing.
- paul 19y agoActually, the vast majority of the feedback is very positive. What I've noticed that is that a lot of the stories getting voted up here are just bashing something popular, such as Twitter, or Facebook.
- utnick 19y agoI think most people didn't read the article... its just a topic that everyone wants to discuss and see discussed
- kirubakaran 19y agoTrue. I always read the comments first. Comments make the main article fall under one of these three categories: 1. Not worth reading the whole post. Here is the summary. 2. Inflammatory / Trollish. But here is a good discussion. 3. Must read the article. Here are some great insights.
- jdroid 19y agoI agree with michael_dorfman's comment below and think it's unfair to call him a troll... Not everyone will be positive and taking that into account is important.
- aneesh 19y agoI'll upmod a crappy article if the discussion it generates is high-quality.
- webwright 19y agoI think that's a problem with voting. A vote up, to a lot of people, is not "this is a great post", but rather "I like this topic". It'd be interesting to know how many people vote up an article BEFORE ever reading it. I'll bet you a nickel that the majority of votes happen that way... Or at least a significant minority.
- mattmaroon 19y agoNo idea. That guy is as inarticulate as he is unintelligent.
- greatapps 19y agoHow disappointing that your only contribution to this discussion is to be snide and rude. I've offered an opinion about an application and the utility I derived on my blog. Thereafter I've commented on the price offered for a company. By definition these are subjective matters. Isn't the point of this forum is for you to articulate where you differ and why, rather than offering childish playground insults.