5 ms·
From the article: 1- the European ice age eliminated almost all of the edible insects in the continent, meaning it's never been a good idea there 2- they live
by zdragnar 8y ago
From the article:
1- the European ice age eliminated almost all of the edible insects in the continent, meaning it's never been a good idea there
2- they live in and on rot and decay, and are otherwise unsanitary
We like meat from animals because it can be butchered without too much contamination. We dislike non-meaty textures- heck, I won't eat chicken feet not only because of the texture, but because what do you think chickens walk around all day in?
Sure, there's limited exceptions- pork cracklins and tripe, though most westerners also refuse to eat those as well.
The comparison to crustaceans is unfair, since most people don't eat the shells of lobsters or crabs, only the fleshy bits. Ultimately, barring some seafood and small game, we're conditioned to not eat the entire animal at once, only the parts that appeal to us. Meat on its own, guts and other soft bits in sausage, bones for broth. Eating insects invariably means that what you eat looks like what it is- an animal.
The article goes on to sing the praises of eating insects- good protein, environmentally friendly, cheap, so on and so forth. That sounds nice, but it doesn't change the appeal of eating an animal whole, or thinking about that same animal living its entire life among a pile of rotten food and poop.
- sandworm101 8y agoIt isn't just preference. There are biological reasons why we avoid insects and small invertebrates generally. There are many parasites that use such things as hosts for part of their life cycle. Not eating insects shields us from these diseases. Take angiostrongylus cantonensis, a tiny worm. It causes eosinophilic meningitis, which is lethal. It is a very rare parasite in the west. Interestingly, when an infection does occur, it is always a male child. Never girls. Never men or woman. Always male kids and the rare teenager. Why? Who else eats slugs?
- yesenadam 8y agoGeez, that sounds very nasty. Worms 'migrating' around in your brain and spine. Clinical Aspects of Eosinophilic Meningitis and Meningoencephalitis caused by Angiostrongylus cantonensis, the Rat Lungworm https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3689484/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3689484/
- bootlooped 8y agoSince we eat animals that we're more biologically similar to than insects, and assuming that parasites prefer to live in roughly similar things, I'm not sure how the parasite risk would be worse by eating insects. If they were raised in captivity, we would have just as much opportunity to pump them full of antibiotics as we do other food animals. The other thing is that sufficiently heating food will kill any parasite present, along with many other things that would do us harm.
- sandworm101 8y agoDont assume. It is very normal for a parasite to go through many very different hosts, each covering a different part of a complex lifecycle. Bacteria and viruses are different.
- GW150914 8y agoJust to add, being a parasite’s intermediate host is often a raw deal, because the little critter didn’t evolve to give a shit about how quickly and brutally it kills you.
- sandworm101 8y agoLike when they take over hosts, change their behavior, ... essentially operate them as zombies.
- throwaway5752 8y agoTrichinosis? BSE? Tuberculosis? Influenza?
- sandworm101 8y agoTB flu and BSE are not parasites.
- JoshMnem 8y agoI don't think eating cooked insects is any more dangerous than eating things like cooked pork. It's only cultural reasons why insects aren't widely eaten here in the US.
- IronBacon 8y agoI don't remember who made me noticing some time ago that fried shrimps don't look very different than fried locusts, but I don't think I would ever be capable to taste the latter... I'm sure they would end transforming insects in a "flour"...
- noobermin 8y agoPerhaps people in cities in the US don't eat animals whole but plenty of Asian cultures eat fish whole for the most part. On my island, the brains and eyeballs of a fish are considered a choice part, reserved for the eldest member of the family. Even in cities in Asia, animals are served in supermarkets whole. It's only in America really that there is this sort of alienation between where meat comes from and what looks like. And by "America", I mean North American cities, because most farmers I know have few qualms about eating meat knowing where it came from.
- jimmy1 8y agoThere are a couple examples in ethno-American cusines. Here in the States, most authentic Mexican food connoisseurs have probably had beef tongue (Lengua) or beef head (Cabeza) tacos. If you have ever celebrated Pascha (Easter) with a Greek friend, you probably had Magiritsa which is a soup made with lamb entrails (if you have hung out with Greeks period, they tend to eat the whole lamb...all of it) And if you have had some traditional South American soups or dishes, a lot of them are made with livers (beef, pork, or chicken). Something else that is becoming a trend lately in some hipster restaurants is sweetbreads.
- andybak 8y agoLiver (and kidney) is pretty common in the UK. Is it not in the US?
- zdragnar 8y agoSignificantly less so. You can find it, but finding someone who would go out of their way to eat it far less so.
- annywhey 8y agoIt's associated with an older style of "white tablecloth" dining that has faded away since the midcentury. If you go to the right kind of small-town diner you'll see liver and onions on the menu.
- 8y ago
- devy 8y ago> I won't eat chicken feet not only because of the texture, but because what do you think chickens walk around all day in? Asian here. We love eating chicken feet. FYI there is a layer of outer skin that get stripped before we marinate and cook chicken feet. Also when the day mass producing insects as food comes, they won't be living in a pile of rotten food and poop.
- zdragnar 8y agoI've a number of friends who moved to my area from Taiwan and Korea, and am well aware of what authentic foods from those countries can be like (including the love of chicken feet). Glad to hear that there's a sanitary way to cook the feet, but the texture was what really killed it for me. I'm a long way from any ocean, so I've never been a big seafood kindof person; texture and flavor of things like beef tongue, squid, octopus and catfish all throw me off as well. Jellyfish wasn't too bad, but I don't think I'd eat it again. Edit: I guess my point was that I'll try anything once, so I'm far less picky than the average American, but some things I can't bring myself to try a second time.
- JoshMnem 8y ago> it doesn't change the appeal of eating an animal living its entire life among a pile of rotten food and poop. I recommend researching how meat is raised. It's probably much more unappealing than how food insects are raised. You can eat insects without knowing that you're eating insects. Here are some insect food products that you can buy in the US.[1] They are good. [1] https://chirpschips.com/ https://chirpschips.com/