4 ms·
Who is telling you that the universe is infinite? Astronomers/cosmologists generally all agree that our current universe (the matter-containing 4 dimensions bi
by sandworm101 8y ago
Who is telling you that the universe is infinite? Astronomers/cosmologists generally all agree that our current universe (the matter-containing 4 dimensions bit we live in) had a defined beginning from which is has grown. There is an outer edge,. defined by the rate of expansion starting from the big bang.
- aikah 8y agoThen what do physicists call what is beyond the edge of the universe? edit: excuse my french ;)
- zentropia 8y agoIt may mean beyond the observable universe.
- Baeocystin 8y agoThe universe may or may not be infinite, for some particular definition of infinity. Our light cone, which essentially defines our universe from our point of view, is distinct and measurably finite.
- khamoud 8y agoI don't think my physician calls the edge of the universe anything unless he's a hobbyist physicist as well.
- jeremyjh 8y agoImagine you are in inside of a giant beach ball, walking on the surface. You will never find an edge, and it is meaningless to talk about such a thing. Yet the space is finite.
- anyfoo 8y agoConversely, the surface of the beach ball has no "center". It's also fun to realize if you blow that beach ball up, from the point of view of any point on the ball, all other points grow further away.
- jaipilot747 8y agoA beach ball has no "edge", but it definitely has a boundary surface, and everything on the other side of this surface is "not beach ball". Now what lies beyond the universe's boundary surface? Is such a surface even present?
- jeremyjh 8y agoThat is indeed where the analogy starts to crumble. The reason is that space itself is curved. It is curved by the matter inside it. Still the property holds that if you travelled far enough fast enough you’d come back to where you started.
- thisismyswamp 8y agoThe Big Bang supposedly encompassed all of space and had no edges.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoHas no edges, and therefore unbounded, but still finite in size.
- deathanatos 8y agoHow can it be both finite in size, and have no edges? To me, it would seem that were it finite, there would be a point at which one would look back, and see the galaxy and clusters that compose the universe; forward would be an expanse of nothingness. But if this isn't the case, then how I can keep progressing forward (presumably forever, as I can't hit an edge) through space, encountering galaxy after galaxy, but it is still finite? Unless this is like RPG games where the edges wrap.
- GW150914 8y agoHow can it be both finite in size, and have no edges? Good question, but find me the edge of an idealized balloon. Where is the edge of a sphere? As to why you won’t come back, remember that spacetime is expanding faster an faster, and you can only travel below light speed. Mind you that’s just one possibility. The universe at large could be a lot of different things, but as humans were causally disconnected from anything beyond the shrinking observable universe. Shrinking from our perspective at least, because of the aforementioned expansion and speed limit.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoIt is exactly the case that the edges wrap (presuming that I understand correctly, of course).
- Neeek 8y agoIt is a running theory that space time could be curved and wrap, or be more traditionally flat, or even be some kind of saddle that means it is still curved but never meets itself again like a sphere does. Recent studies point to it being flat though, if I remember correctly.
- auntienomen 8y agoWhat you're describing is the 'visible universe'. There may well be other parts of the cosmos outside of our light cone. Einstein's equations allow it, and we have no way of knowing.
- ajuc 8y agoNo, visible universe is what we can see, it's defined as all the points close enough in spacetime that light from there had enough time to get to us. Visible universe is centered on Earth, much smaller than what GP was talking about, and decreasing steadily (because at the edge of it expansion of space pushes stuff outside faster than speed of light).
- cygx 8y agoat the edge of it expansion of space pushes stuff outside faster than speed of light Not quite: According to the cosmological standard model, the visible universe will continue to grow (ie new galaxies will continue to come into view) - but only asymptotically, ie until a maximum size given by the comological event horizon is reached. However, the parts of the universe that aren't gravitationally bound to us will become fainter and fainter and increasingly resdhifted, and eventually, we'll be unable to detect other theoretically visible galaxies due to technological limitations.
- ajuc 8y agoIf they are moving away from us faster than speed of light because of expansion of space - wouldn't it mean at some point no new light from them reaches us? Even ignoring the limitation of equipment?
- cygx 8y agoIn my opinion, that whole 'moving away from us faster than c' business is not really a good way to think about this: For one, we can see to a redshift of about 10, corresponding to a comoving distance of about 30Gly, and a recession velocity of about 4c (four times the speed of light!) at time of emission. There's a cosmological event horizon. Light emitted from within will reach us in finite time, light emitted from without won't. Similar to how a distant observer will never see on object falling into a (stationary) black hole cross the Schwarzschild horizon, we won't see galaxies crossing the cosmological horizon.