53 ms·
My experience about 'culture fit' was that it was a code word for ageism. Sometimes they'd be even more direct if I pushed back. This wasn't at the end of a 4
by rmason 8y ago
My experience about 'culture fit' was that it was a code word for ageism. Sometimes they'd be even more direct if I pushed back. This wasn't at the end of a 45 minute interview, it was in the first five minutes after I'd already passed the technical review. Might not be true in every instance, but I absolutely cringe when I hear that phrase.
- gmmeyer 8y agoDon't forget about race.
- draw_down 8y agoIt’s really anything that doesn’t match the team’s (or individual interviewer’s) notion of what a good developer looks like. So it could be how you dress, how you talk, even if you are white and male and not over some age threshold. And I suspect much of that is not conscious, which of course makes it difficult to talk about and address.
- JimboOmega 8y agoI got the job I have now while, for lack of a better term, being "visibly trans", the only person of my race on the team, and also well into my 30s. I don't think it'd be possible for me to look more different than I do from my teammates (especially how the team looked when I started - it's grown and become somewhat more diverse since) That said, I do worry about how my presentation will be perceived elsewhere, it comes time to move on.
- draw_down 8y agoIt’s not about looking the same necessarily, it’s about whether you fit the person/team’s image of a good developer, which sometimes can be very narrow. If the team is diverse that is less likely to be the case, of course. Also, people totally get discriminated against for being trans (though I’m glad to hear you didn’t). That seems indisputable to me, so I’m not sure what your point is unless you’re saying that it doesn’t always happen, which, sure it doesn’t.
- some_account 8y agoWe may not like it but yes, age matters for culture fit. I prefer people saying so instead of giving me bullshit reasons.
- Taylor_OD 8y agoBut saying, "We think you're too old to be a good culture fit" is illegal while saying, "You're not a good culture fit" isn't. That's likely why companies don't say so directly, no?
- lovich 8y agoMight as well say "we may not like it, but yes, race matters for culture fit". Both are highly illegal and pretty unethical.
- chosenbreed 8y ago>...Both are highly illegal and pretty unethical Agreed. But should they? I mean if I start a company with no recourse to public funds why should I obliged to employ someone I wouldn't want to work with? I understand why it is illegal. I think the ethics are debatable too. Most importantly, I think both are routinely violated under some guise such as 'culture fit', etc.
- ivraatiems 8y ago> I mean if I start a company with no recourse to public funds why should I obliged to employ someone I wouldn't want to work with? Because otherwise certain classes of people will never be able to get certain classes of job, despite being qualified, because the people who hold those jobs are all members of another class who doesn't want to work with them. For example, at various times both women and African Americans couldn't become doctors. There is no evidence that women or African Americans are worse at being doctors than men or white people, but the people who _were_ doctors (mostly men and mostly white) at those times didn't want to work with them, and culture suggested they were not capable of performing that profession. Preventing discrimination against protected classes is a balancing act - balancing the infringement on the liberties of a group that systemic discrimination brings vs infringement on the liberties of an individual or single entity by saying they cannot make choices based on certain criteria. The protected classes that exist now (such as gender and race) exist because far more harm is done to far more people when they don't exist, even factoring in the fact that certain people will lose the ability to make certain choices based on all the criteria they'd like to.
- stcredzero 8y agoMy experience about 'culture fit' was that it was a code word for ageism. I've experienced people figuring out my age when looking at my resume, then weirdly warping the questions while accusing me of Googling the answers in response. (Based only on hearing me type. I was scripting a Python script to give the answer.)
- aeternus 8y agoInteresting, that instinct to Google for the answer is actually one of the 'culture fits' that we look for. There are a surprising number of candidates & engineers that simply give up when they encounter a hard problem.
- protopeer 8y agoperhaps if you make it clear that it's okay to Google, then you might get a different outcome. it's highly common for candidates to assume that in an interview, it's not allowed or highly penalized to do so.
- aeternus 8y agoWe do, we let them use their own laptop (or supply one), and also allow them to finish at home.
- nicoburns 8y agoI've never googled something in an interview (typically for the face-to-face part I'm not at a computer so that would be difficult, and googling under pressure seems like a bad idea). But I have told interviews that I don't know, but I'd google it if I needed to in a work situation, and that's always been received positively. I guess it depends on what they're asking about though. Some stuff you should know off the top of your head...
- maxxxxx 8y agoI would google for the answer too if the expectation was to find the right solution quickly. I have rarely had an interview where they gave me time to think through a problem. The wanted "the" answer quickly without much thinking.
- notyourday 8y agoIt is more than agism. It is a cover for all kinds of "We cannot tell this person we won't be hiring them because we dont like them as they are a protected class so we need to come up with a creative excuse"
- dba7dba 8y agoMy friend once interviewed for a low level position at a well known startup company. He passed HR, took and passed competency tests, passed interview by future coworkers. Last interview was with manager of the team who happened to be a young woman who was a brilliant coder. He didn't get it. He was sure that her expression changed negatively very slightly once she saw him on the video conference. My friend is quite sure it was due to either ageism or subtle racism. He is not white. He's moved on but it confirmed to him fair is not a word he believes in anymore.
- basseq 8y ago"Culture fit" is a double-edged sword, and implies you have a strong handle on what your culture is in the first place: both the good and the bad. A candidate who is conflict-adverse, for instance, would not be a "culture fit" in an organization where decisions are made in screaming matches. The problems come when your culture is toxic, particularly for certain types of people. If older candidates wouldn't be successful or happy in your work-20-hours-a-day-know-it-all culture, that's a culture problem, not a dog-whistle for ageism. Some interviewers use "culture fit" to explain a not-like-me discrimination against people with a different gender, background, age, race, etc. Those people are generally toxic—but also indicative of an organizational culture that tolerates those biases by employees who are external-facing representatives of that company. As a candidate, if you're ever rejected as a "bad culture fit", you probably dodged a bullet. That's a negative reflection on the company, not on you.