2 ms·
Actually, aircraft dont need to register flightpaths. A transponder code and generalized flying time is all that is needed in vfr situations. Even in ifr cond
by sandworm101 8y ago
Actually, aircraft dont need to register flightpaths. A transponder code and generalized flying time is all that is needed in vfr situations. Even in ifr conditions, with filed flight plans, those plans are not meant or used for collision avoidance. Radar and human eyeballs keep aircraft apart.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- godelski 8y agoActually you don't even need generalized flying time. You can take off, fly, and land however you please. You can talk to no one the entire time. The only thing you need to do during VFR is make your calls around the airport (call before you enter a runway, downwind, and other landing calls (and if you're going from private airport to private airport, you don't even need to do that)). If you're staying out of controlled airspace you don't need to talk to anyone, but you should make a few announcements. Rules are very different if you're outside A,B, and C airspace.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoAir travel is a bad analogy, unless you only think of ATC activity near the runways. Unlike airspace, things put in orbit are permanent on the operational timescales. They also have limited, if any, capability to dodge other objects. It's more like development of a zoned piece of land, except if you build too close to another structure, both buildings explode.
- sandworm101 8y agoI'm not sold on the crowded space thing just yet. Looking at who is in the most danger, I am forced to consider agendas. The most, really only sats at risk are low-flying stuff in polar orbits. The danger space is the area above the poles where all polar orbits cross. Those are mostly going to be imaging sats. And of imaging sats, only those wanting 100% planetary coverage bother with a true polar orbit (90+ inclinations). The stuff most in danger are therefore the military radar/imaging sats in low orbits: spy satellites. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KH-11_Kennen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KH-11_Kennen Note the orbital inclinations, all between 90 and 100 polar orbits in the 250-1000km range (LEO). Once up to medium orbits (GPS, 22,000km) or geostationary (42,000km) risks become minimal to nothing. Space up there is huge, the relative speeds much slower. It is an open question whether collision between sats is even relevant considering the risk of colliding with any number of natural objects.
- akiselev 8y agoThe danger isn't to any single satellite or mission, the danger is to future human space flight [1]. We have existing systems for handling liability and financial compensation for accidents in space but we don't realistically have a way to clean up our trash in orbit, especially in a cascading scenario. We have little data on how big the debris is from colliding satellites and how it spreads so for all we know, when any disaster happens, it could be seeding LEO with small particles capable of shredding other satellites and we just haven't launched enough to run into them yet. If Kessler was right and there is a point of no return, a single such accident could shut humanity out from spaceflight for decades or centuries. Not that I think we're anywhere near that point, but it's important to realize why these regulations are important and why they must never be ignored. Down the line, someone's decision to rush a mission due to market/shareholder pressure could rob many generations of their final frontier. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome
- sandworm101 8y ago>> it could be seeding LEO with small particles capable of shredding other satellites and we just haven't launched enough to run into them yet. There is plenty of natural sat-shredding material up there now. In most orbits there is more natural material passing through than man-made. Earth is hit by over 100 tonnes of natural material per day. Take the sphere of orbits, and many thousands of tonnes pass by daily, far more than the mass of the sats up there. If we turned all the sats into sand, it wouldn't increase the collision risk in comparison to the shower of natural debris we already deal with. https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/asteroids/overview/fastfacts.html https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/asteroids/overview/fastfa...
- TeMPOraL 8y agoLooking at the list from [0], all the orbits involved are indeed high-inclination, but not that polar (inclinations from ~70 up to ~110). You prompted my interest though, I'll look for detailed points of the collision later on. I don't think people are really worried about GEO-height collisions, but there's already lots of stuff flying in LEO, with much more to come in the near future. -- [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satellite_collision#Artificial-satellite_collisions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satellite_collision#Artificial..., under "Unintentional high-speed collisions between active satellites and orbital debris"