4 ms·
I still fear the Silicon Valley ethos of "move fast and break things" is infecting areas where this is outright dangerous: healthcare, self-driving cars, satell
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
I still fear the Silicon Valley ethos of "move fast and break things" is infecting areas where this is outright dangerous: healthcare, self-driving cars, satellite launches.
It's one thing if your social networking app goes down for a bit or someone's favorite feature is broken, it's quite another to do something that can have severe negative consequences (in this case, for humanity at large) if something goes wrong.
- sova 8y agois that a valley slogan or a fb slogan?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- unit91 8y agoFB slogan, Valley mindset. Lest we forget, many in the Valley have worked at FB, want to work at FB, or want to be FB.
- garmaine 8y agoMany is not all, or in this case even most.
- caymanjim 8y agoIt's certainly not limited to Facebook. Uber, Lyft, AirBnB, Theranos (to a lesser extent), and countless other companies are operating with a mindset of "ignore the regulations, break the law, society will catch up." Regardless of whether or not you agree with the regulations being broken, they are largely in place for a reason. Sometimes it's a good reason, sometimes it's not. The penalties are rarely enough to deter people chasing a profit. Let's stop treating "the rules don't apply to me" like an innovative business idea, and call it what it is: behaving like a child.
- garmaine 8y agoHow, exactly, did this ignoring an overreach of FCC authority endanger humanity? Not generalizations, but this specific case. When you look at the details of this case, it really doesn't paint a picture in the way you're interpreting it. Edit: Explaining for the down-votes. The orbit these things are in are easily managed and outside of major space traffic zones. The size of the satellites means they will all burn up on re-entry. Also, see my comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17953257 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17953257
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> an overreach of FCC authority endanger humanity? One, it isn't overreach. Certifying and registering satellites is the FCC's legal duty. The threat comes from untracked satellites becoming untracked orbital debris. This is the same reason we register flight paths. > something that FCC doesn't do and doesn't have any insight into assessing The international organization that deals with orbital registration and regulation is the ITU [1]. The FCC is charge with managing our interactions with the ITU because, historically, all satellites were communications satellites. The FAA clears launches (not satellites). (Air Force supervises launches. USSPACECOM hasn't really existed since it was merged into USSTRATCOM in 2002.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Telecommunication_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Telecommunicatio...
- garmaine 8y agoOf geosynchronous satellites. The distinction is very important.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Of geosynchronous satellites What is limited to geosynchronous satellites? ITU jurisdiction covers low-earth orbits because the risk from orbital debris and radio interference is not limited to GEO. Partly as a result, FCC jurisdiction is not limited to GEO.
- saudioger 8y agoI think people largely ignore that the phrase originated in non-human-life-critical software? You can't just use it as a mantra for everything (but people are!). Imagine walking into your dentists office and seeing a "move fast and break things" poster. Like sure, if you're making a social media app... break the shit out of it... but it's not a good idea when a minimal QA process can slam your car into a wall.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoI think the difference is that the original phrase suggested you break your own things, but the meaning has now evolved to criticize companies breaking things around them.
- jrockway 8y agoI feel like all technological breakthroughs are a result of "move fast and break things" and it isn't a new concept. For example, consider normal non-self-driving cars. They kill tens of thousands of people a year. If you were writing the design document for them today, you'd mention something like "if people drive them while drunk, they could kill a lot of innocent people" and your lawyers would have a heart attack. But nobody did that, they just made them, and now society is impossible without them so we accept the cost. They moved fast and broke things. I doubt that SpaceBEES will be as transformative as the automobile, but, approval or not, there they are in space. (Also, it's the FCC that's the government agency involved here. The FCC does not regulate space travel, they regulate radio frequency assignments.)
- TeMPOraL 8y agoI'm not sure if this holds for cars. They were few and far between when first deployed. It's the growth of the car deployment that caught us by surprise and placed us in the quite ridiculous situation we're in today. And as the roads are now dangerous places, laws rightfully limit the amount of experimentation that can be done with them. Space, similarly, might have been "move fast", but "break things" was limited to risking lives of people participating in each individual project. I suppose the original meaning of "move fast and break things" involved only breaking your own things, but this meaning evolved, and when used to criticize today startup culture, it connotes breaking other people's things.
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoAnd cars are, still, one of the leading causes of death in the US. Doesn't this illustrate the GP's point?
- carapace 8y agoBut the thing is cars are a damned insane mode of transportation. You said it yourself: "They kill tens of thousands of people a year." Not to mention all the injuries and mayhem. The current design of our transportation system is a death and mayhem lottery that we force everyone to play willing or not. Kids, old people, pets, no one is excluded from this egalitarian meat grinder. There's no responsible argument for "move fast and break things". "Drop dead gorgeous": lead poisoning in the 18th century because of lead makeup. Antibiotics: resistant "super-bugs'. Plastic: fills the oceans and clogs terrestrial ecosystems. Internal combustion engines: pollution. Farming: habitat destruction. Hairspray: holes in the ozone layer. Easy long-distance travel: non-native invasive species. Computers and the internet: mass surveillance and cyber-crime. Split the atom: made bombs. It is far past time to learn from our mistakes and think carefully about the shape of our desired future.