2 ms·
I’m not an art history major, but why does a work of art require a backstory? Or a meta-story? Why is a screensaver not “real” art? It seems so limiting. That’s
by ryandrake 8y ago
I’m not an art history major, but why does a work of art require a backstory? Or a meta-story? Why is a screensaver not “real” art? It seems so limiting. That’s a beautiful painting and the painter is very talented, but there is no existential dread evident in the brush strokes, no social commentary on the intersection between class warfare and feminism, so it’s not “real art”. Who makes these rules?
It’s like when you hear a young pianist play Liszt perfectly or a Rachmaninov piece better than Rachmaninov did, and the critics say, “Well there was no emotion there, no struggle—she has a long way to go.” Bullshit! It was great! Why can’t art just be appreciated itself, without all this “story” baggage?
- gedy 8y ago> Why can’t art just be appreciated itself, without all this “story” baggage? Because that eliminates the in-group, experts, elite, etc. Hence all the "rules" and terms like "outsider art", etc
- tern 8y agoYou can similarly ask, 'how could art exist without "in-group, experts, elite, etc."'? Why in the world would anyone create all these bizarre objects?
- holdenc 8y agoOf course, if you like it, that's really all that matters. But art history, and contemporary art, are not really determined by polling the audience for what's liked most. Instead it's determined by those who have made it their passion to understand what makes great art and drives great artists. And they are able to agree on what makes it into art history (at least the Anglo American version) pretty well, for better or worse.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoWhy can’t art just be appreciated itself, without all this “story” baggage? I think art expresses something inside a person. Sometimes, people find it meaningful on its own. Sometimes they don't and understanding can be enhanced by "story" or whatever. Kind of a case of sometimes words get in the way and sometimes words help bridge the gap between two minds. /random internet stranger who didn't actually read the article, just your comment