5 ms·
Judging by the list of "Ignorance, war, poverty, dirt, disease, frustration, hunger, fear, overwork, superstition all vanished." it seems many of us are living
by tonyedgecombe 8y ago
Judging by the list of "Ignorance, war, poverty, dirt, disease, frustration, hunger, fear, overwork, superstition all vanished." it seems many of us are living in a utopia yet we still aren't satisfied.
- saagarjha 8y agoAre you? Do you have no worries in the world?
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoIf we take each of those issues: Ignorance - developed countries have never sent so many people to university. War - Is less common in recent history and the wars we do get involved have fewer casualties. I know people will raise Iraq but you only need to go back as far as Vietnam to find a conflict that was an order of magnitude worse. Poverty - Absolute poverty is very low in the developed world and decreasing elsewhere. Dirt - Soap is cheap. Disease - Smallpox, Malaria, Measles, Rubella, Syphilis, Rabies are all eradicated or falling heavily. Cancer is only so common because we live so long. Frustration - Liberal values have given freedom to a lot of people that had been oppressed. Hunger - Food has never been so cheap. Fear - I live in the UK, there is nowhere in my country that I feel is out of bounds for me. Overwork - Jonathan Sachs has a really good presentation on this, our hours have been falling for decades. Also technology has freed us from much backbreaking work.
- saagarjha 8y agoI don’t disagree that it’s getting better, but it’s disingenuous to suggest that there aren’t still problems in the world that should be solved.
- umvi 8y ago> but it’s disingenuous to suggest that there aren’t still problems in the world that should be solved I don't think anyone's arguing this. I think the argument is that we don't realize how good we have it since Orwell's time. What he described is many people's (especially on HN's) effective reality.
- annabellish 8y ago>Ignorance - developed countries have never sent so many people to university. And yet, ignorance is still a significant problem in society, whether it be today's flavour of bigotry, a continued denial of the dangers of climate change, anti-vaxers, et cetera so on and so forth. >War Less war is certainly not none, and the consequences of our current wars are hitting as close to home as they have in living memory. Terrorism, both domestic and foreign, are problems for real people. >Poverty "Absolute" poverty maybe, but that doesn't mean that huge chunks of the western world aren't worrying about money constantly. Effective poverty is a tremendous issue. Well, I could keep going, but I won't - suffice to say, all of those things are still issues. They may not all be the same, or even as bad in some "absolute" sense, but they're still relevant.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- beaner 8y agoMany do not. There is a theory of something called the Power Process, which states that for people to be happy, they need goals which require effort, and need to achieve at least some of those goals. The lack of meaningful goals which require effort in the first world may be responsible for much of the depression, suicide, and other issues that plague us today. I found this Medium post which quotes the relevant parts: https://medium.com/chris-messina/surrogate-activities-the-power-process-16203dda87 https://medium.com/chris-messina/surrogate-activities-the-po...
- fucking_tragedy 8y ago> There is a theory of something called the Power Process, This is not a theory in the scientific sense. It's an idea Ted Kaczynski, the Unabomber, wrote about in his manifesto.
- beaner 8y agoOk, not sure how that changes the point.
- jvln 8y agoMight be the reason why endurance running is on the rise.
- otakucode 8y agoWhat lack of meaningful goals? I find it very hard to believe that any human being is ever in a position where they find it hard to see meaningful goals to strive for. The lack of ability to achieve any of those goals, however, I could easily see being a problem. You can't really achieve anything that requires concentrated effort if you've got to work 40 hours a week so that you can eat.
- umvi 8y agoI think GP's point was that measuring utopianess is difficult because it's all relative (like poverty or torture). In other words, you can't measure it directly. For example, if you went to the future and noted a person owned a flying car, had infinite food and a huge castle would you be able to measure the poverty level of that person? No - it depends on how much his peers have. If his peers own spaceships and planets, then he is rather poor by comparison.
- moate 8y agoI'll wait for the list of places in the world in which there is no fear. Just that part of the list alone covers 100% of the population.
- fucking_tragedy 8y agoThe article details why utopias defined as the absence of pain or the abundance of a scarce resource present a problem in terms of happiness.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> Ignorance Ever present, if you look around. > war Always on somewhere on this planet, and always a threat when the relations between yours and other nations become tense. > dirt, disease, frustration All ever present, and experienced by everyone to great extent. > hunger In the western "utopia", it's usually a job mishap or a big medical bill away. > fear, overwork Ever present and experienced by most of us. > superstition Displayed by half of the population, if not more. Even if we happen to live without experiencing most of these for a while, it's only the most ignorant that don't realize how fragile such situation is.
- 13415 8y agoFear is everywhere nowadays, it seems to power capitalism or at least is encouraged by it. I suspect the reason is that actual capitalism (as opposed to the ideal construct) is more based on Social Darwinism and capital accumulation than on trading for the mutual benefit of all market participants.
- pitaj 8y ago> Fear is everywhere nowadays, it seems to power capitalism or at least is encouraged by it. To the contrary, fear powers the State. > I suspect the reason is that actual capitalism (as opposed to the ideal construct) is more based on Social Darwinism and capital accumulation than on trading for the mutual benefit of all market participants. Depends on what you mean by capitalism. Capital accumulation is useless in a market economy if you don't re-invest it (which is a mutually beneficial trade in itself).
- CryptoPunk 8y ago>>I suspect the reason is that actual capitalism (as opposed to the ideal construct) is more based on Social Darwinism and capital accumulation than on trading for the mutual benefit of all market participants. The ideal construct of a market economy is not based on "trading for the mutual benefit of all market participants". As Adam Smith so sagely put it 250 years ago: >>It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own interest. We address ourselves, not to their humanity but to their self-love, and never talk to them of our own necessities but of their advantages. The mutual benefit is an emergent outcome, not a conscious intent of any particular participant. Advocacy of market economics is largely based on a sober outlook on the nature of man, and a pragmatic plan for improving its condition.
- skrebbel 8y agoTotally! You just described my life.