4 ms·
It’s that tug of war. When the Feds shut backpage because it was essentially a platform for illegal thigs, people were on the fence (buy it’s only a platform).
by mc32 8y ago
It’s that tug of war. When the Feds shut backpage because it was essentially a platform for illegal thigs, people were on the fence (buy it’s only a platform). Here, on the other hand where FB is merely incidental, sure, let the hammer comr down. Mind you, I’m not a fan of FBs at all, just pointing out what seens a discrepancy.
- Rjevski 8y agoThe thing is, I don't really mind if illegal things are happening on a dedicated platform. Users who are determined to break the law will break it anyway, so I don't care if they have a platform explicitly designed for doing so. Having illegal things on a general-purpose platform is another thing. This can encourage a broad chunk of people to break the law, sometimes even unknowingly. This is way worse than the Backpage scenario.
- mikeash 8y agoI imagine the discrepancy is because a lot of people think that sex work shouldn’t be illegal, and there are good reasons to think that shutting down sites like Backpage just makes things worse. Whereas here, most will probably say that this stuff should be illegal, and getting it banned from Facebook is probably an improvement.
- mc32 8y agoSex work is not the same as human trafficking —which was one of the things they were indicted for. Most people who are okay with consentual adult sex work are definitely not okay with human trafficking (and its implications)
- mikeash 8y agoRight, but didn’t they shut down Backpage for their involvement with sex work, claiming that there were knockon effects for sex trafficking? I don’t think they were directly advertising trafficking.