8 ms·
>It's hard to explain things to laymen, especially in subjects like economics, where everyone thinks they've got a complete understanding of the mechanics after
by salawat 8y ago
>It's hard to explain things to laymen, especially in subjects like economics, where everyone thinks they've got a complete understanding of the mechanics after watching a couple YouTube videos.
The refuge of an expert who maybe isn't as much an expert as he thinks he is. Not saying that's you GP, but A) laymen aren't as dumb as you think, B) they don't have an incentive to obfuscate things to preserve or justify their status as an expert, and C) the field of economics suffers enormously from the curse of mathematics. The deeper you go, the less relevant it tends to be at predicting the real world.
I recently took a month to start digging through a slog of economic theory to try to counter my own Dunning-Kruger effect in the field and had to stop because it just made me angry at the sheer scale of uncompensated positive feedback loops and reliance on statistical multiplexing that our economic system is built on. Any system that depends on all depositors NOT needing their assets back at the same time is fundamentally a scam.
A system like Fractional Reserve which is inherently inflationary biases the entire system against those with the smallest and least inclined to grow income streams from the get go.
Economics is difficult when you JUST look at money movement to facilitate virtual growth. When you start looking at economics as a means to an end to get PHYSICAL work or change done instead of just in the vacuum of a theoretical accountant's model, you can see some very disturbing trends in the direction things are going.
And again, that's just from someone from the outside looking in who isn't relying on their economic expertise to win them their daily bread.
Full disclosure, my research revolved more around the ways in which "conservative" (not political, but minimum risk tolerant) investment behavior incentivizes and guaranteed corporate behaviors which optimize for growth figures at all costs, damn the externalities. I'm becoming one of the people who thinks we've been doing things really wrong since about the 80's, but the foundations were laid long before that; we just didn't recognize it because humans generally suck at handling long period trends where the period is > a human lifespan, and labor had enough clout to eke out a greater chunk of the revenue stream at the "cost" of creating a slow growth economy in terms of capital gains by non-practicing investors (I.e. investors who weren't themselves laborers, but were living off managing their wealth's capital gains). Don't ask for data though, my day job has precluded me from being able to do the hard part of the research... (Actually doing it.) I at least think I've almost got the falsification criteria worked out though. Just need to sit down and figure out what data I actually need to give me a complete picture to reason from.
- cycrutchfield 8y agoNot to be insulting, but you sound like exactly the kind of person the GP was talking about. “Outsider who rejects the field’s orthodoxy” comes across more like a crank than anything else.
- IncRnd 8y agoExcept that he is correct and even gave the example of why he is correct.
- pjkundert 8y agoWell, the practitioners of the field of Economics reject Hazlitt and Taleb as cranks, so I’d take their opinions with a grain of salt.
- MagnumOpus 8y agoTaleb is not a crank, he is an obnoxious snake oil salesman - packages well-known truism as wisdom invented by himself, slates the orthodoxy, collects lots of money for his hedge fund, then loses it all and earns millions writing books about how all the other hedgies who actually made money are "doing it wrong".
- salawat 8y agoHave you ever been stuck in a room full of really smart people? It can be a very dangerous place to be. Smart people are EXCEEDINGLY good at rationalizing just about anything. You can get stuck in a state where your discourse becomes like an Ouruboros, nice and circular, never getting anywhere. Occasionally you have to question whether or not your fundamental assumptions are still valid. For most of our country's history, even WITHOUT the post 80's economic zeitgeist to guide us, we did just fine treating worker's with respect, and a fair wage. We have transformed in the span of 30 years years into a highly polarized, economically fractured, industrially poor nation. Our political discourse has gotten worse and worse, and trust is at such an all-time low that we're doubting not just our government's capacity to lead and protect us, but also each other. I've met people from just about every side of the socio-economic spectrum, and even a few of the last remnants of the "Greatest Generation", who LIVED through the Great Depression. My thoughts have thus far been convincing to most with sufficient time to elucidate them. Something is FUNDAMENTALLY wrong. I'm not saying ALL economists and their economics are Quacks. I'm even somewhat fond of Taleb, if only because he is one of the few who had the courage to even DOUBT. The field, however, is due for a reckoning, and a reconciliation with reality,and the Unknown unknowns. As I stated in a previous post, there are too many structural problems built into the way our system works. No natural system can stay cohesive under conditions demanding continual growth in an environment with finite resources. It doesn't happen. Ever. Computing, biology, physics, mathematics, control theory, chemistry, anthropolgy, politics, logistics, and most importantly HISTORY has shown over and over again that while periods of massive development and growth DO happen, eventually, the inputs required to sustain it or the excessive outputs it generates overwhelms the operating environment's capacity to supply\absorb it/them. Something has to give. I'm not willing to auction off the only legacy I have worth passing down for the next generation for short term gains. Which is increasingly the direction we as a nation seem to be developing toward economically. It's my opinion, and a verifiable fact to anyone willing to even make a halfway credible attempt at tracing the steps that have led us to where we are now, analyzing the forces that were at play, and taking the time to try to LEARN from the trials and successes of the past. Don't just take my word for it. DO some research. Convince yourself. Don't leave it to someone else. I don't want a damn person to follow me on faith. Convince yourself, and go whatever direction you desire, but for the love of all that's holy, be honest. The info is out there. I'm willing to entertain my theories are wrong, as they almost certainly are, that's why it's called research. Why should the field of economics not be willing to entertain the same? Anyway. Certifiable crank signing off.