3 ms·
Western countries have always spied on each other, jostling for position and influence. That is nothing new. Openly declaring hostile intent against an ally - t
by simonh 8y ago
Western countries have always spied on each other, jostling for position and influence. That is nothing new. Openly declaring hostile intent against an ally - that's new. I'm not sure if people in the US really understand how horrified everyone, of every political stripe are about Trump's behaviour towards us and the elected Republican leadership's complicity in it.
It's not just about Trump anymore. He could be kicked out of office at the next election, sure. But the elected republican leadership, who have their own democratic mandate, are just rolling over and letting all this happen. If they can't be relied on now, they can't be relied on after Trump either. As a conservative Brit, that grew up politically during the titanic partnership between Reagan and Maggie, this is all bewilderingly horrible.
I still remember the Falkland war and the way that, while it took the US a while to realise what was happening, in the end here was never any real question over here that we would be able to rely on the US in the end. I don't think that would have been substantially different under any subsequent US president even right up to Obama. But now? I don't think there is any such confidence. Can you imagine a British Prime Minister worrying about what Trump might tweet after we sank the Belgrano?
- fetbaffe 8y agoEU is not really the same as the UK, especially if UK is leaving the EU. Trumps criticism is against the EU, Trump is a nationalist, something he is scolded for by the left, but everyone wants to forget his nationalism when it fits the argument that he is anti-UK (or any other European country) And not to mention, Trumps "foe" comment was in regard to trading with EU, not a military conflict.
- simonh 8y agoI'm perfectly aware he's a nationalist, why do you think I'm forgetting it? I'm concerned principally with what he's doing because of it. Trump's trade actions against the EU, including Britain, and other allies were on national security grounds. He's publicly sided with Putin against his own national security agencies. None of this is encouraging from a European perspective. Nobody is anticipating military conflict between the EU and US, but hostile acts via security agencies? Especially targeting trade and economic activities? Operations on that front that would have been inconceivable just a few years ago cannot be discounted.
- mistermann 8y ago> I'm not sure if people in the US really understand how horrified everyone, of every political stripe are about Trump's behaviour towards us and the elected Republican leadership's complicity in it. Is this a factual statement? What is the source? And I don't mean this in a snarky way, I mean it in a literal, epistemological sense. I regularly read, both in forums and in the headlines, that "everyone" believes certain "things", but whenever I did just a little into the details I almost inevitably find that in reality, there is an extremely wide variety of opinions. After all, life is extremely complicated. So, likewise, I am interested interested in reading a bit deeper into this particular fact so I can be a more informed voter.
- simonh 8y agoFair enough, loose terminology. Trump does have support over here, that's a fact, but bear in mind those quarters tend to be the nationalist end of the spectrum. Where in their priority list do Britain First people put Trump or the US? Not in first place, that's for sure. They're no happier with steel tariffs, cosying up to Putin, etc than anyone else. The best they can say is that he doesn't really mean it. But he's doing it, so that argument is really wearing pretty thin.
- mistermann 8y agoAnd to all of this, I will once again ask the very same question: Are these statements factual? What are your sources? In a literal, epistemological sense, by what means did you obtain the information you have written in your comment? EDIT: And it appears I have once again deviated from the acceptable narrative and had my commenting privileges suspended for the day. This is how perceptions are managed.
- simonh 8y agoI didn't down vote you or censure you, and I'm not trying to score points with this post. I suspect our fellow commenters are reacting negatively to what is perceived as pedantry. Every post here is implicitly representing the opinions and perceptions of the poster. My post was based on my immersion in British and European political culture and meida, and the opinions I read and hear through many different channels - newspaper and web news articles and opinion pieces, TV news and interviews, radio, etc. We are having a conversation, not posting peer reviewed fact checked academic papers. If you doubt or disagree with a post then it's much more effective and useful to others to provide reasons for your disagreement or counter-arguments and evidence. Again, I'm not trying to be argumentative, this thread is off the home screen and effectively dead. We're just communicating with each other at this point, so I'm just trying to explain how the commenting culture works, as I understand it. Best regards.