4 ms·
> Divisive content is the king of online media today, and YouTube heavily boosts anything that riles people up [...] I look upon this idea skeptically. In my
by ravenstine 8y ago
> Divisive content is the king of online media today, and YouTube heavily boosts anything that riles people up [...]
I look upon this idea skeptically. In my experience, the content delivered to me is as divisive as the videos I've already watched. If someone is getting divisive content, that's probably the content that they want to watch. Is it really up to YouTube to determine if a person has been watching content that's too divisive, like a bartender who cuts off a someone who's had too many drinks?
When I log out of my YouTube account or open YouTube in incognito mode, all I see are viral videos and nothing that's "divisive". For example, the YouTube homepage without being logged in shows prank videos, Rube Goldberg type fascination videos, educational videos, Mexican music, daytime TV crap, SNL skits, and pop music.
So basically, in order to get to the divisive stuff, you have to already be using search queries that will bring one to political commentators.
But then what should be done? If someone is watching a lot of videos by the far left, should the recommended videos proportionally include more videos by right wing commentators? Is this really what people want?
Sorry that this is tangental from the actual point of the article, but I've read of this idea multiple times before and it's always asserted as if it's a matter of fact, but I'm not sure I buy it.
- richthegeek 8y agoI find that once Youtube thinks you want divisive content, it serves it up to you pretty regularly. As an example, I have plenty of "X riles up SJWs" type videos and also their counterpart "X angers sexist Gamergaters" despite not watching these and trying to actively say "don't show me these things". Unfortunately, one bad click from Reddit and Youtube thinks I want this tripe. It's not solely related to "divisive" content though - the same is true of content related to Fortnite, Buzzfeed, and anything else that mostly consists of clickbait content. Youtube is just optimising for engagement, regardless of how that engagement affects the viewer.
- lsc 8y ago>I look upon this idea skeptically. In my experience, the content delivered to me is as divisive as the videos I've already watched. If someone is getting divisive content, that's probably the content that they want to watch. Just a counterpoint, I think it depends largely on the subject matter. my 'disengage the brain' videos are mostly tool teardowns and slow-motion videos of milling machines, or reviews of '90s luxury cars. If I let youtube pick the next video a few times in a row while I'm watching car videos, I end up in supercar land, (which is not very much fun for me, but not divisive or anything.) If I let youtube pick the next video a few times while watching tool teardowns, I sometimes end up with more interesting tool talk, but I often get survivalist stuff, and sometimes 'sovereign citizen' stuff starts to creep in.
- noobermin 8y agoAre you sure about this? Often times, I find yt recommends videos in a manner to keep me on yt (like previous songs I've watched on repeat). And you bet divisive content gets people on their site. May be in 2010 it gave related content. That was what I found most useful and I discovered a lot of content that way, that is, it did work in the way you suggest: showing me what I want. Now, it definitely shows me what I don't really but will probably cause me to load another page.
- Mediterraneo10 8y ago> If someone is getting divisive content, that's probably the content that they want to watch. I recently used YouTube on a brand new browser installation to watch some clips from various adult cartoons. That was all. No other search terms, no interest in politics. Soon after, the Recommendations on the right side of the page started to be filled with – besides other cartoon clips – all kinds of polemic culture-war videos, on both sides of those wars. That really impressed on me just how funneled towards these videos people can be even if they show no overt interest in those topics.
- pjc50 8y agoI have a saved screenshot of when I was watching gaming videos (XCOM2) and all the recommendations were also XCOM2 videos .. and a live stream of UK far-right rabble-rouser Tommy Robinson. I suspect (but of course can't prove without secret youtube data) that there's enough of a crossover between gaming and the far right that any gamer will eventually see far right videos, far more likely than they will be shown "far left" videos (these must exist, but I've no idea who they might be?)
- annabellish 8y agoThe YouTube far-right community is much bigger than one might expect. There's a lot of actual fascists on youtube who get a lot of algorithmic promotion, but leftist youtube tends to be smaller and much less extreme - no "far left" by most definitions. The same tends to be true in most spaces in my experience. Whatever the "far left" is tends to be a poorly defined boogieman, not a cohesive group--almost as if it were the eternal enemy of standard far-right ur-fascist theory!