5 ms·
Do people here still think that "killer" domain names matter? I mean, will you really make back the extra 40k you invested in joke.aday.com instead of going wi
by dagw 16y ago
Do people here still think that "killer" domain names matter? I mean, will you really make back the extra 40k you invested in joke.aday.com instead of going with the $10 dlyJoke.com or todaysjoke.org (to take two currently available domains I just made up).
Or to put it another way. Has anybody seen any significant increase in business after switching their site to an expensive "killer" domain?
- jonknee 16y agoDropbox, Facebook, Groupon and Mint all come to mind. Update: missed a really obvious one--Twitter. It launched as twttr.com and was nearly impossible to explain to people. I don't think it would have gone mainstream without the URL that includes vowels.
- iterationx 16y agoSuperUser cost 70K
- mey 16y agoSurvivor Bias?
- JeremyChase 16y agoWith the exception of Mint, the other examples were already quite successful before improving their domain name. Establishing causality in these cases is tenuous.
- jonknee 16y agoI seriously doubt Groupon.ThePoint.com would today be valued at over a billion dollars. Dropbox went on a tear after their domain purchase, but I suppose it's possible they would have anyway (though I know from personal experience it was tricky to tell people about Dropbox and then try and remember the domain). http://www.google.com/trends?q=dropbox http://www.google.com/trends?q=dropbox (Dropbox.com was acquired in October 2009, right where growth turns from linear to exponential.)
- qeorge 16y agoDropbox.com was also acquired right after they got a ton of funding, which could also partially explain the exponential growth. (Not arguing with you, just pointing it out).
- Confusion 16y agoThe left part of any graph that shows exponential growth looks linear. You could just as well argue that the growth has been exponential from the start.
- brk 16y agoI'm only remotely familiar with Groupon and Mint (know of them, never used them). But both Dropbox and Facebook were building brands around those particular words, yet had domains that were not the branding words (getdropbox.com, thefacebook.com). Facebook also started out initially as a college-only thing, then opened up to the world, so it's hard to say their growth was linked only to domain name changes. In either case though, (the)facebook.com could have just as easily been "allmypals.com" or something similar where the branding matched the domain name in a more direct fashion.
- alttab 16y agoThis was my first thought as well. Who the hell does someone think they are when they start with an expensive domain name and think that they can build a business from that? Your domain name / brand name is only a portion of the pie, and considering the reputation of Mahalo, starting with nothing but a domain name and a potentially poor co-founder match will not bring quality technical people to Santa Monica.
- IgorPartola 16y agoOn top of that I think I just don't want to deal with domain name squatters. It seems to me to be a dirty business and I don't want to support it.
- notahacker 16y agoit's easy to start with an expensive domain name if all you're doing is monetising type-in traffic. Not sure kokua falls into that category though...
- IgorPartola 16y agoThis is all IMHO: I think it depends on the type of the product. If you have a blog, you better have a killer domain name. If you have a web app, just let the bloggers with the killer domain make it a household name. One exception to this is don't choose a name that people can't spell or pronounce.
- webwright 16y agoThey matter HUGELY for any search match. WhitePages.com (from my understanding) gets scads of direct traffic and googles for "white pages". It's HUGE for seo (spend a few hours doing random searches and see how many searchquery.com domains you see). Not to mention brand credibility. Others have mentioned Mint.com (which they paid a pretty penny for). Dropbox got dropbox.com pretty recently (switching from "getdropbox.com"). And, word of mouth marketing. Plenty of examples of companies succeeding with weak domain names, but yeah-- I think "killer" domain names matter a LOT.
- TomOfTTB 16y agoI'll concede your white pages point because people search for the term White Pages. But do you really think people who aren't already familliar with the companies are doing blind searches for Mint or Dropbox? More to the point do you think pemople will really be searching for "aday" or "kokua" ("I need some help with this math problem so I think I'll just randomly type Kokua into Google and see what happens")
- TomOfTTB 16y agoI'd actually go further and point out many if not most of the sucessful startups in recent memory haven't had "killer domain names" Google, Twitter, 37Signals and yes even Ycombinator are all things that meant nothing until their founders made them mean something. Once that happened their uniqueness became an asset
- jpwagner 16y agogoogle's a number. and i bet the added benefit of calling wherever they worked the google-plex cinched the deal.
- CGamesPlay 16y agoNo, a googol is a number. A googolplex is also another number.
- jpwagner 16y agowhat a worthwhile response!
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- endtime 16y agoA little beside the point, but for your own edification, Y-combinator actually did mean something: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Y-combinator http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Y-combinator
- TomOfTTB 16y agoI debated adding that to the list because I knew someone was going to post this :) In fairness 37 Signals also means something just not a specific concrete thing that someone would search for
- 16y ago
- csel 16y agoGreat point. Considering a lot more attention are on mobile now, websites are becoming more like landing pages. More people i guess choose to remember application names as opposed to remembering domain names. Just put the application name on Google Chrome browser (where you used to put the url address) and it will show you the web address. No need 'killer' domain names anymore. As far as spending $125k on domain names, he could have created at least 2 - 3 killer apps for that price, especially with his marketing influence.