3 ms·
Why can't companies use the SSS or IRS, etc., for this kind of verification? Why have to go through a third party to get information back from the government?
by mc32 8y ago
Why can't companies use the SSS or IRS, etc., for this kind of verification? Why have to go through a third party to get information back from the government? Where required, they already need to do an eVerify anyhows, don't they?
- toomuchtodo 8y agoThere really isn't any reason. This is similar to how Turbotax exists even though the IRS could file your taxes for you. I believe this product is even in development at the IRS based on an interview with the US Digital Service IRS team several years ago (although they were primarily targeting mortgage origination firms as customers of this data, think Quicken's Rocket Mortgage product). TrueWork could move faster than the IRS can internally, but eventually the IRS' product would be canonical with organizations (while at the same time, salary data privacy laws continue to be enacted state by state prohibiting the release of salary data to perspective employers).
- mcherm 8y agoThey use Equifax because the government has actual privacy policies and requires an individual's permission to release information. The government may also not have offered this exact service (they offer a service to release your entire tax form, but I'm not sure they offer one to release only the salary and employer from your W-2's).
- Dowwie 8y agoActually, funny you should ask that. Lately, I have been hearing advertisements on podcasts about the Department of Homeland Security offering such services. They're not offering this as a free service, though. Taxes only pay their salaries. You wouldn't expect that to be sufficient
- segmondy 8y agoIRS doesn't have APIs. I've done some work with them, you have to manually upload CSV and download the results hours later. Automating it is against their TOS. For one of the data I get from them, I've the option of getting in printer on paper, DVD or magnetic tape.
- craftyguy 8y ago> Automating it is against their TOS. Why would anyone want something outlawing automation in their TOS? Is their 'service' maximizing human effort and minimizing throughput?
- 394549 8y ago> Why would anyone want something outlawing automation in their TOS? Is their 'service' maximizing human effort and minimizing throughput? It could be that they want to make usage painful to keep control of the data. Automated scraping/bulk downloads would be much easier to detect than TOS violations that occur after the data is downloaded. For instance, I wish my county recorder's office forced people to manually retrieve property public records rather than providing them electronically. The extra cost would make it unfeasible for data brokers and people search websites to slurp up all the data for resale, while still allowing access for legitimate purposes.