3 ms·
>In practice, the variational methods are not competitive at all with deep learning models I really don't see why these two things need be pitted against each
by ur-whale 8y ago
>In practice, the variational methods are not competitive at all with deep learning models
I really don't see why these two things need be pitted against each others.
What you're describing (Euler-lagrange applied to computer vision problems) is a direct application of the calculus of variation to the image itself.
It's rather naive because it uses an extremely weak representation of the content of the image (i.e. a bunch of pixels which essentially means working with a piecewise-constant basis of the functional space), and as you noted, it is easily beaten by modern techniques.
However: Deep neural nets are nothing but another, much more powerful "basis" of functional space (I put "basis" in quote because they're not linear. OTOH, they're generative).
A deep net is a finite set of real numbers that maps to a point in functional space, and any arbitrary continuous maps from R^n to R^p can be approximated by deep nets given enough weights and neurons.
So, if deep nets are dense in functional space, and "training" a deep net is nothing but solving a minimization problem in functional space, then I don't see why the "calculus of variation" ==> "PDE" via Euler-Lagrange route can't bee applied to training deep nets instead of backprop-based minimizers.
Now, if you're claiming that backprop works better than solving the PDE induced by Euler-Lagrange on the functional minimization problem of training a deep-net, I'm very happy to believe you, but I've yet to see literature demonstrating this.
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoThe variational representations used in image processing are much more complicated than you suggest. In many cases, they are developed with semantic models that inform grammars of what the image can be composed of, and directly model things like occlusion, cusps, edges, blur, etc., when postulating a joint functional space that can describe the “energy” of an image, which then minimizing gives not only pixel values but also parametric curves for boundaries and sometimes also labels. It’s essentially a way to encode semantics as prior distributions over possible images, then variational methods “optimize” for the posterior parameters given some data. I’m trying to say that that whole exercise listed above, conceptually, is basically a failed idea compared with solving the same problems using deep learning to automatically discover what that manifold looks like in parameter space and transform it directly to the output space of practical interest (segmentation boundaries, etc.).
- ur-whale 8y ago>The variational representations used in image processing are much more complicated than you suggest Fair enough, but my main point stands: has anyone tried to apply Euler-Lagrange and a PDE solver to the problem of training a deep net or is it obvious that backprop-based methods will work better?
- enriquto 8y agonot exactly the same thing, but here you have a "Deep Neural Networks motivated by Partial Differential Equations", that may pique your interest https://arxiv.org/abs/1804.04272 https://arxiv.org/abs/1804.04272