4 ms·
likely to be met with scoffs of “good riddance” My first thought was that this may also cast light on the rise of the trans rights movement. If men are becomin
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
likely to be met with scoffs of “good riddance”
My first thought was that this may also cast light on the rise of the trans rights movement. If men are becoming less male, surely this relates to so many people saying "I'm really a woman trapped in a man's body." or vice versa.
This may also help explain why trans people are so often met with open hostility as "freaks" etc. No, I am not defending their mistreatment.
But given how charged a topic that is, I imagine bringing it up will get my comment flagged to death, not taken seriously.
I'm a fairly traditionally feminine woman and spent a couple of decades as a homemaker and full-time mom. I am routinely met with open hostility from self proclaimed trans activists, feminists, etc.
I personally like "manly men" and that's also not a PC thing to admit to. So I will suggest it isn't just men the world is saying "good riddance" to. It's also women in some sense.
If you want to argue that, please stop and think before dismissively attacking me. People talk all the time about how gender is a social construct and is not merely the bits between your legs. I stayed home with my kids and that had a profound impact on how I think about many things. And the way I think is alien to that of career women and they are frequently openly hostile to it.
- thomasfedb 8y ago> I am routinely met with open hostility from self proclaimed trans activists, feminists, etc. Hostility towards what? I assume they attack a view you hold, rather than your being a stay-at-home mother.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoOh, lots of different things. As best I can tell, the hostility is towards me personally, not a specific view per se. I've been accused on HN of being transphobic for attempting to speak about women's issues. I don't really care to dig up a whole lot of examples to convince skeptics. I was homeless for nearly 6 years and only asking for help with trying to figure out how to make money online. I got damn little support and was actively dismissed, especially on a different forum that likes to imagine it is female friendly. I don't think it really is. Anyway, those painful experiences made it quite clear to me that a lot of people literally would like to see me dead. I'm aware that callous indifference isn't something most people will take seriously as a form of attempted murder, so I don't actually want to talk about this. Additional hostile dismissal of my opinions of my experiences won't change my opinions and, ironically, are unlikely to be seen as supporting evidence for my point.
- thomasfedb 8y agoSo you think an online community that knows you only by handle is personal hostile towards you for some reason other than your expressed views?
- ppseafield 8y agoThat's a little bit uncharitable, right? "Expressed Views" are interpreted by the people that read them. Plenty of people online mistakenly infer things in other people's posts and attack that instead. Or they imagine that the poster probably holds another position (which they may or may not) and attack that.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI post as openly female. Women generally have a much harder time online than men. I was homeless for a long time and open about that. Plenty of people were openly contemptuous. Sexism and classism are alive and well. They impact social behavior online as well as off.
- fit2rule 8y agoFWIW, I'm a manly-man, and I routinely attract aggression from non-cis folks because I've had kids and enjoy being a Dad. I think this is just par for the course, personally - if people did like having kids and being 'traditional' in their family future, they wouldn't be non-cis...
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI've got one word for you: Hypocrisy. I spent 9 months being extremely supportive of a MtF trans youth in crisis who expected and demanded that I be totally accepting of who and what they were. Then they had a cow and shit all over me for mentioning that "pretty boys" weren't my cup of tea and reamed me out about how that's prejudice. So their preferences and predilections must be unquestioningly validated. Mine? Just another BS excuse for the individual to heap more verbal abuse on me. We eventually parted company. Last I heard, they are still telling lies about me to other people. That's absolutely not the inclusiveness that so many people claim they want. It's hypocrisy. What they really want is to preserve the Lord Of The Flies pecking order where people on top get to shit all over people on bottom, but they want to be the people shitting on others, not the people being shit on. It's not actually an attempt to create some lovely egalitarian society. It's more like a desire for revenge and that revenge is frequently aimed at individuals who didn't actually harm them.
- acct1771 8y agoI read it as hostility toward her being in a "traditional gender role".
- dfdsfdsjfhdsjfh 8y agoLord help me for even responding to this nonsense, but here I go. I'm trans, prior to starting hormones my sperm count was 91.90 million/mL (close to 1973 benchmark noted in the article.) Please don't spread harmful speculation.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThat's what they call "anecdata" or N=1. It isn't evidence that my thoughts are nutso and irresponsible behavior.
- newscracker 8y ago> I'm a fairly traditionally feminine woman and spent a couple of decades as a homemaker and full-time mom. I am routinely met with open hostility from self proclaimed trans activists, feminists, etc. > I personally like "manly men" and that's also not a PC thing to admit to. So I will suggest it isn't just men the world is saying "good riddance" to. It's also women in some sense. I think, in this context, we need better and likely newer vocabulary. I don't believe that others would despise you or any other woman or man or an intersex person or someone in transition for liking certain characteristics (physical and/or behavioral) traditionally and historically associated with men. The issue seems to be — while we're untangling all the discrimination, stereotyping and prejudices — that the current and older terms (like "manly man") reek of all these negative things that are being questioned (where newer ways are being sought to deal with). The impact of such broad terms is wider than what people may generally think of. To make a comparison (which may be taken differently by different people), it's like using the "N" word and assuming that even a neutral or seemingly positive reference should be accepted by others. Language is changing all the time and adapting to the times. In this particular case, I believe we should break down what something like "manly man" means into constituent parts and try to use decoupled (from the original term), yet concise and non-triggering, ways of expressing the same. It may not be easy. It may sound weird at first. But it's something we need as a society. Lest this be dismissed as "oh, we just need new words to fix the world", I'd like to reiterate that the basis is to allow thoughts to change.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoFWIW, after posting, I did contemplate adding: Contrary to popular opinion, manly man and misogynistic asshole aren't actually synonyms.
- newscracker 8y agoI didn't even think of these two terms together in this context and I don't think of those as synonyms, and my usual thoughts in this case are about the characteristics and attributes that are used to discriminate against those who don't seem to be "manly men" or those who seem to be "manly men", while society (or parents or others) wants them to be and fulfill what they (the others) think is their traditional role. Tradition is not set in stone. Nothing is. The clash is sometimes with certain behaviors, but it's also many a times with prejudiced associations that discriminate and affect others. P.S.: I also believe that short pieces of written words and sentences can be misinterpreted online, and probably malice attribute to where there is none.
- sixstringbudha 8y agoI have a similar explanation to this dropping hormone levels phenomenon. It is simply just that it does not require to be a 'manly man' in these days to have the same amount of "success", as it required in the old times. For example, take the whole mating game. Earlier, you had to look good/manly, need some quick thinking, timing and wit to pick up women. But now those things are not so much required. I think multiple factors have contributed to this. But I think the all encompassing one is capitalism. And things like these are the an emergent result, of trying to maximize profits, and thus it is molding the very source that it generate the profit from, namely the human population. Simply put, much less profits can be made from a manly (manliness being comprised of things like but not limited to, looks, having some individuality, own principles and views and a taste for independence) and intelligent population than it can be made from a feeble/stupid, but heavy earning population. I am not saying that there is some conspiracy that is trying to accomplish this. But it might be a case of a death by a thousand paper cuts. I mean, like every time you try to sell something to the public, by social conditioning, you might be inadvertently contributing to things like this...
- pokemongoaway 8y ago"This may also help explain why trans people are so often met with open hostility" should be >>>>> "This may also help explain why trans people feel they are so often met with open hostility" Thanks for being a home maker, which is the age-old proven roll for producing the best offspring - and society's future generations. It is merely the marketing of insecurity that allows so many to propose that "CEO" is so much more virtuous than "home maker" for a woman of child bearing age. None of the "modern alternatives" are alternatives at all - in that they've not been proven in the least to be comparable in effectiveness. And the people pushing hormones on pre-pubescent children because they're "questioning their gender" should be called out and ridiculed for the sake of these children's lives! The fact that it isn't PC to admit that you like men ("manly men") is so ridiculous, but I agree that it is true (that is shunned). People are gaining political platform merely on the basis of the credential of being gay, trans, etc! Since when did wanting to have sex with a certain kind of person become so righteous?! This is all reminiscent of the culture of sexuality that the Greeks had during the final stages of their empire. The people who are mischaracterizing the issues we have with this generally as issues we have with them personally are not being intellectually honest. The destruction of the male & female gender roles, which balance and compliment each other - with no proposed alternatives with long-term studies - is suicidal for our civilization. Thank you for speaking up... I think there are way more women who share your views & experience than almost anyone is admitting.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- meesterdude 8y ago> I personally like "manly men" and that's also not a PC thing to admit to there's nothing political about liking what you like. You don't need to justify yourself, your preferences or their reasonings to anyone. That's half the point of the sexual liberation movement. > I'm a fairly traditionally feminine woman and spent a couple of decades as a homemaker and full-time mom. I am routinely met with open hostility from self proclaimed trans activists, feminists, etc. for raising kids? i didn't realize investing in future generations was controversial. You have just as much right to exist and go about your life as they do or anyone else.
- doombolt 8y agoThere's no longer any sexual liberation. Instead you are told that you need to be controlled from outside in order to not be taken advantage of. It's 50s once again?