3 ms·
> I think you have a misconception about GR here. No, you do. Everything I am saying is taken straight from GR textbooks--mainly Misner, Thorne, & Wheeler (197
by pdonis 8y ago
> I think you have a misconception about GR here.
No, you do. Everything I am saying is taken straight from GR textbooks--mainly Misner, Thorne, & Wheeler (1973) and Wald (1984)--and peer-reviewed papers, such as Hawking's original paper on black hole evaporation. You need to go read them.
> In GR, spacetime isn't just an "optical device" that delays rays cast in an absolute reference.
I never said it was. The paths of light rays in GR are determined by the geometry of spacetime. "Optical illusion" is one way of trying to describe the effect of that in the case under discussion. But the effect is there regardless of what you call it.
> In relativity, the behavior of light rays is actually closely related to interpretation of time and space. You can't separate the two.
This is just another way of saying that the paths of light rays in GR are determined by the geometry of spacetime. Which is true, but to figure out what that means in a specific scenario, you need to properly understand the spacetime geometry in that scenario. You evidently do not.
> In fact, the definition of (relative) local time is given exactly by the rate a "light clock" ticks when communicating periodically to a "light clock" located elsewhere.
There is a limited set of scenarios in which this works, but that limited set does not include the case under discussion (Alice falls into a black hole while Bob remains far away). In general in GR, there is no well-defined way of comparing "times" for spatially separated observers. The only well-defined time is local--proper time along a particular observer's worldline.
> Alice falls into BH -> Alice approaches EH -> Alice's BH evaporates -> Alice finishes falling into the BH
I never said that was the sequence of events. It isn't. The correct sequence of events is (note: this is what happens to Alice, Bob does not see all of these events--see my other post in response)
Alice falls into BH -> Alice approaches EH -> Alice finishes falling into BH -> Alice's BH evaporates
If you don't understand how that happens, you need to go study GR textbooks. The model that gives the sequence of events I just described has been well understood for several decades now--Hawking published the first paper using it in the 1970s.
- darkmighty 8y agoWell you've convinced me that, if Hawking's model is as you say, it's obviously incorrect :P I don't know if this is just a mathematical simplification that doesn't impact conclusions about existence of EHs and singularties, but it all looks fishy.
- pdonis 8y ago> you've convinced me that, if Hawking's model is as you say, it's obviously incorrect Why? Note that I'm not claiming (and Hawking never claimed) that his model is experimentally verified--that's obviously impossible since Hawking radiation from any black hole we can observe is many orders of magnitude too faint to observe, if it exists and has the intensity predicted by the model. But the model is perfectly self-consistent. > it all looks fishy Why?
- darkmighty 8y agoI don't have time to explore this topic in depth right now (way too much on my plate already, and I'm not that fast or brilliant), but I suspect there's literature on this topic. Something I could find is this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firewall_(physics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firewall_(physics) Basically, my intuition is more or less in line with this firewall phenomenon and that no particle crosses a true event horizon, even in their own frame, and no certainly no singularity.
- pdonis 8y agoThe firewall hypothesis is one of the quantum gravity hypotheses that is an open area of research, yes. But even if the firewall hypothesis ends up being confirmed (which won't happen any time soon), that does not mean it's the only consistent hypothesis. Your claim was that the classical GR model, and Hawking's original model, were inconsistent. They're not. They might end up not being correct when quantum gravity effects are taken into account, but that doesn't make them inconsistent.
- UpshotKnothole 8y agoThe Firewall as spelled out in the original paper is widely considered to be unlikely, not in the least because it violates the equivalence principle. There are weaker versions of the firewall based in M-Theory which exist because there is no singularity, and the event horizon is actually the surface of the fuzzball which takes its place, but that’s a different sack of weasels.