2 ms·
> I'm pretty sure black holes have been observed indirectly What we have observed indirectly are compact objects that emit no light, but contain a large enough
by pdonis 8y ago
> I'm pretty sure black holes have been observed indirectly
What we have observed indirectly are compact objects that emit no light, but contain a large enough mass in a small enough volume that they can't be anything else but a black hole, if we only take classical GR into account.
As I responded in another post just now, it is possible that black holes, in the sense of objects with actual event horizons (boundaries of regions from which light will never escape, even in the infinite future), cannot exist when quantum gravity effects are taken into account. If that is the case (and it is not clear whether it is--as I said, this is an open area of research), then the objects we call black holes based on our current observations won't have actual event horizons--eventually, in the very far future, light will escape from those compact regions. But they will still have apparent horizons, i.e., surfaces from which outgoing light is not escaping now (or for a very long time in the future). And that, in itself, is sufficient to show that the issues raised by darkmighty are not valid.