3 ms·
> There are variations on this that are more problematic (which I've never seen solutions to). Then you haven't spent much time looking at actual textbooks on
by pdonis 8y ago
> There are variations on this that are more problematic (which I've never seen solutions to).
Then you haven't spent much time looking at actual textbooks on GR, since all of these issues are addressed there. (Not to mention in many peer-reviewed papers in the field.)
> if no matter appears to reach event horizons, how can they (event horizons) form in the first place (i.e. exist in our universe)?
This is the same fallacy as the fallacy that nothing can actually fall into a black hole because it looks like it takes forever from the outside. Oppenheimer and Snyder published a mathematical model way back in 1939 that shows how a black hole can form in a finite time from the gravitational collapse of a massive object, as seen by an observer falling inward on the surface of the object. The collapse appears to take forever as seen by a distant observer, but this is an optical illusion caused by the effect of spacetime curvature on the paths of light rays. This has been studied for decades and is thoroughly understood.
> While it takes forever for matter to fall in (again to outside observers), it takes finite time for black holes to evaporate via Hawking radiation.
Wrong. First, if matter is falling in, the hole is gaining mass, not losing it, so it will never evaporate even though, in principle, it is emitting Hawking radiation (in practice this radiation is many, many orders of magnitude too faint to detect for any black hole we can observe).
Second, if you include quantum effects, and therefore Hawking radiation in your model, you've changed the model, and it is no longer true that a distant observer will never see anyone falling into the hole. Instead, the distant observer will see light signals emitted by objects falling through the hole's horizon at the same time the distant observer sees the hole evaporate. (At least, that is the case in the simplest model, the one Hawking used when he first published his prediction of Hawking radiation. More complicated models have been developed since, and we won't know which, if any, of them is really correct until we have an experimentally confirmed theory of quantum gravity.)
> I'm not a physicist, but my speculation is that Black Holes don't really exist, they're just a limit of a process that approaches but doesn't converge to a singularity, which I think is unphysical.
Your speculation is uninformed and wrong. It is possible that an actual black hole, with an actual event horizon, is impossible when all of the laws of physics, including the laws of quantum gravity, are taken into account. This is an open area of research. But if it turns out that actual black holes cannot exist, it won't be for any of the reasons you give.
- darkmighty 8y ago> This is the same fallacy as the fallacy that nothing can actually fall into a black hole because it looks like it takes forever from the outside. Oppenheimer and Snyder published a mathematical model way back in 1939 that shows how a black hole can form in a finite time from the gravitational collapse of a massive object, as seen by an observer falling inward on the surface of the object. The collapse appears to take forever as seen by a distant observer, but this is an optical illusion caused by the effect of spacetime curvature on the paths of light rays. This has been studied for decades and is thoroughly understood. But isn't equating the two observers incorrect? That is, when speaking of 'formation time', we are speaking of the formation time by observers at infinity, free from the effects of local curvature. What I understand is that all observers must agree on reality, thus on whether the BH forms at all: if the infalling observer makes it through an EH and into a singularity, then those exist (by definition) as unique reality. But evaporation seems to complicate this classical GR view understood for a while: since now outside observers see finite-time quasi-evaporation, infalling observers must observe this phenomenom while infalling, and actually before reaching the EH. There's no way I can see that: 1) EHs and singularities (i.e. Black Holes as a steady-state phenomenon) exist; 2) All observers agree on reality of their formation and evaporation. I defiantly conclude they don't exist (or I'm missing something major) :) That is, black holes in nature would be something akin to a extremely time-dilated "Object trap" without singularties (although perhaps it must gain an apparent horizon?).
- pdonis 8y ago> isn't equating the two observers incorrect? There is no "equating the two observers". > when speaking of 'formation time', we are speaking of the formation time by observers at infinity No, we aren't. The hole isn't formed at infinity. The time that is being talked about for observers at infinity (or more correctly, very far away) is the time it takes light rays, coming outward from the object that is collapsing into a black hole, to reach those observers. The curvature of spacetime near the horizon is such that it takes longer and longer for those light rays to get out to the observer far away, the closer to the horizon they are emitted. At the horizon, outgoing light rays do not move outward at all, due to the curvature of spacetime there, so they never reach the observer far away--hence that observer never sees the horizon form. But, as I said, that is an optical illusion caused by the curvature of spacetime. > What I understand is that all observers must agree on reality, thus on whether the BH forms at all All observers agree on observable events and measurement results that they can all observe, yes. But if an observer cannot observe a particular event (such as the horizon forming) because spacetime curvature prevents light rays from that event from ever reaching him, then he can say nothing at all about whether that event happens or not. > evaporation seems to complicate this classical GR view understood for a while It complicates it in the sense I said before: that observers far away, instead of never seeing infalling objects cross the horizon, now see those objects cross the horizon (more precisely: see light rays emitted outward by those objects when they crossed the horizon) at the same time they see the hole evaporate (more precisely: see light rays from the hole's final evaporation). It does not mean what you claim, that infalling observers will see the hole evaporate before they fall in. The spacetime geometry of an evaporating black hole (i.e., including quantum effects) is different from the spacetime geometry of a classical black hole that never evaporates. The statement that a distant observer never sees an object cross the horizon is only true of the latter, not the former. > I defiantly conclude they don't exist (or I'm missing something major) :) The second is the correct choice. You need to stop being defiant and start learning what the models of black holes in physics actually say. > black holes in nature would be something akin to a extremely time-dilated "Object trap" without singularties (although perhaps it must gain an apparent horizon?) To us far away, an apparent horizon looks the same as an event horizon, and works the same--all the things I said above would still be true (at least for the time we have been observing--see below for how long it would take for differences to become observable) if the objects we observe and call black holes actually have only apparent horizons (because of hypothetical quantum gravity effects that, as I've already said, are an open topic of research), not event horizons. And all of your criticisms would still be wrong. (In at least some of the hypothesized quantum gravity models, there is no singularity and no event horizon, only an apparent horizon; but to us far away, the object looks and works the same into the very far future; it takes something like 10^70 years for the difference to be observable.)