3 ms·
They only argue that the impact was enough to offset a decline from 270 ppm CO2 to 250 ppm CO2 to instead wind up at 280 ppm CO2 at the preindustrial stage. Ov
by lamontcg 8y ago
They only argue that the impact was enough to offset a decline from 270 ppm CO2 to 250 ppm CO2 to instead wind up at 280 ppm CO2 at the preindustrial stage. Over about 8,000 years. Call it 40 ppm CO2 over 7000 years to make the number a little larger and its 0.005 ppm CO2/yr.
We're currently increasing CO2 in the atmosphere by 2 ppm CO2/yr or 350 times faster.
So he's not claiming that pre-modern agriculture had a huge impact on CO2 levels, but that those CO2 levels do have rather large climate impact over time. He does this by comparisons with prior ice age due to similarities in the precession of the Earth. The paper is about MIS19 which is 18 interglacials ago, which provides a good analog in the orbital properties, and which there is CO2 data for in ice cores.
That can then be correlated with the paleoclimate record showing glacial inception happening ~10,000 years after the maximum in MIS19. Using the actual paleoclimate data from MIS19 to control a GCM for MIS1 they run the GCM forwards from the glacial maximum and find that the mean global temperature falls by 1.2K and that the high Arctic cools by 5-6K with 3K falls in temperature over most of the Arctic and Siberia.
That paints a consistent picture where by right before the pre-industrial revolution the Earth should have been cooler and continental shield glaciers should have started forming across Northern Canada and Siberia. And this matches the paleoclimate record of MIS19.
If this seems counter intuitive at all, then your calibration of how much human impact is necessary to produce global climate changes (particularly over thousands of years) is likely off.
That also means that the argument that climate change will be beneficial is correct in a way, but pre-industrial humans already made that impact. We're well beyond the climate impact that would produce a consistent, beneficial boost to global temperature and are blasting the furnace.