2 ms·
I think it might, but not without much more complexity. As you point out we hear phrases and refrains etc. - you'd need to both generate phrases, and then gene
by vidarh 8y ago
I think it might, but not without much more complexity. As you point out we hear phrases and refrains etc. - you'd need to both generate phrases, and then generate structure by making use of and transforming (mutating, transposing, investing etc.) phrases.
Listening to his examples what struck me was exactly that: You could hear the outline of something, but it was killed instantly by the lack of internal consistency: What at first sounded like the outline of phrases were self similar, sure, but there was way too little outright repetition.
It also fell flat at capturing well established rules of chord progressions - I have the same impression as you: individual changes were ok, but even with my very, very superficial understanding of composition I know that certain progressions add tension and others release it, and, and pairs of chords that work well together sound just plain weird if they're not part of a bigger structure that also follows the rules.
I'm reminded of a program printed in Compute! or similar in the 80's that was meant to let anyone play music. It worked surprisingly well. The way it worked was simply to only allow note progressions that were likely to result in something that at least sounded "like music". But you still needed to understand rules for composition to go from something "like music" to something that sounded pleasant.
I feel like his example falls in that category: He's made it sound "like music", but it's something most people can beat by buying a book on improvisation that explains a few simple chord progressions and some very basic rules. Going from that to something that sounds like an actual proper piece of music is another matter.