5 ms·
> It would be a violation of several important rights (theirs) for a government to regulate how they choose to run their charity, They formed a charity to get
by DanBC 8y ago
> It would be a violation of several important rights (theirs) for a government to regulate how they choose to run their charity,
They formed a charity to get the tax relief from that same government. With that relaxation on taxation comes a restriction on activity.
- TimTheTinker 8y ago> They formed a charity to get the tax relief from that same government. Not at all. They formed a charity because they wanted to make a positive difference in the world. That US law originally recognizes charities, churches, and other non-profits as tax-exempt is a a recognition of the solid, positive contribution to society that such organizations make. Their tax-exempt status was originally granted as such, and not with any idea of using it to stipulate how they should do things. So I strongly disagree that tax-exempt status somehow grants the government authority over an organization's affairs. It would be better to revoke all organizational tax exemptions than to begin to use it as such leverage.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> That US law originally recognizes charities, churches, and other non-profits as tax-exempt ...Is a false statement. It doesn't “originally recognize” any such thing. It permits charities, including churches and some other non-profits with specific functions, to voluntarily apply for status that includes tax exemption, a public subsidy via tax deductibility of donations, and a wide variety of restrictions on behavior.
- loco5niner 8y ago> They formed a charity to get the tax relief from that same government. Nope. They formed a charity to help people.