3 ms·
Now why doesn't the site use my HTML query to deliver me the content which is adjusted to the browser I use? Instead of showing me the 5 browser icons etc, it s
by acqq 16y ago
Now why doesn't the site use my HTML query to deliver me the content which is adjusted to the browser I use? Instead of showing me the 5 browser icons etc, it should just show me instructions for my browser.
Hint: you don't need JavaScript to do that.
- mfukar 16y agoI don't think UserAgent reporting is even remotely reliable. Is there an alternative way to detect browsers?
- acqq 16y agoIt is very reliable for the given task. If the site is supposed to help an ordinary user, detecting robots or spoofing is completely irrelevant.
- mfukar 16y agoNot only robots or spoofing modify UserAgent. Mobile devices, HTTP client apps, validators, libraries, feed readers, or privacy-concious users can also do that. Then again, if one's user base includes none of the above, one can certainly enjoy maximum reliability.
- jauco 16y agoIt does. Sorta. It makes your browser the one in the middle. Also: try opening the site with javascript turned off.
- acqq 16y ago> It does. It makes your browser the one in the middle Doesn't. > try opening the site with javascript turned off. Exactly how I tested it: in the middle was Chrome. But I use Opera. Now consider: If I'm ordinary user and I'm supposed to be helped to turn on JavaScript, I certainly don't need to see five darned icons "IE FFox Chrome Safari Opera" as the main information presented on the page. I came to the site with one browser, not with five of them. In that browser, the JavaScript is turned off. I certainly don't need the long page with the the instructions for all of them. But as tav noted here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1794305 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1794305 (although I don't agree to his "it is good as it is") -- the bigger problem is: if I'm using IE and I turn JavaScript off, I certainly know how to turn it on. So who's the target user? I still posit that the target of the OP site are only lazy web developers ("ooh lookie I can link to this site from my noscript")