4 ms·
The extreme left aren't involved in mass murder at anything like the extent that the extreme right are. When looking at HVE groups the far left appears rarely,
by DanBC 8y ago
The extreme left aren't involved in mass murder at anything like the extent that the extreme right are.
When looking at HVE groups the far left appears rarely, those lists are full of either militant Islamist or Far Right groups.
The focus on the far right happens because it's the far right that are murdering people.
- meowface 8y agoWhat is HVE? What far-right groups are you referring to specifically?
- jazzyjackson 8y agoHomegrown Violent Extremists There's been numerous reporting on the surge in popularity of anti-government militia groups, tho it looks like most of it comes back to a report by Southern Law Poverty Center, which you may or may not take as a reliable source. [1] https://www.splcenter.org/20090731/second-wave-return-militias https://www.splcenter.org/20090731/second-wave-return-militi...
- notahacker 8y agoTo be fair, whilst the modern, Western extreme left are generally less violent, there's no shortage of extreme left media that's designed to engender hatred of perceived groups of enemies far more than propose solutions, and certain extreme left factions which will go out of their way to defend state use of violence by notionally left wing or "anti-imperialist" governments, offer explicit support or defences for certain militant Islamist groups, or in the context of the modern UK extreme left, identifying "Zionists" to be purged from public life...
- dnomad 8y agoYou have to be willfully blind not to see the obvious connection between far right groups and violence. Both the US and the UK have seen dramatic increases in far right terrorist attacks and equivocating this clear, observable phenomenon with bogeymen on the left is very disingenuous. If you're actually concerned with rising extremism you'd focus on the more pressing issue which is very much not the anti-imperialists.
- notahacker 8y agoYou'd have to be wilfully blind to ignore both my opening sentence acknowledgement that the far right is on average more actively violent than the modern, Western far left and the fact that groups with an extreme agenda and the will to endorse violent action exist on the extreme left, as does a social media funnel leading from very reasonable causes to campaigns to purge people on account of imagined political allegiances linked to their ethnicity, arguments that death threats for political opponents are actually justified, solidarity with pro-violence Islamists and people who advocate extend the principle of punching perceived fascists well beyond Richard Spencer. Few things are more damaging to political discourse than thinking it's unfair or disingenuous to criticise anyone who's not as bad as the neo Nazis...
- simula67 8y agoCitations please
- ahana27 8y agoThe extreme right are currently mass murdering people? What? Where?
- yesenadam 8y agoWell, most recently I've heard about hundreds being killed in Nigeria by Boko Haram and hundreds of social leaders murdered recently in Colombia. Plus whatever countries the US is currently slaughtering people in.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ahane27 8y agoI'm not familiar with the situation in Colombia, but Boko Haram is extreme right?! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boko_Haram#Ideology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boko_Haram#Ideology Also, the US is extreme right? I would consider them to be globalists, which is quite the opposite in my book.
- pmorici 8y agoIn the mid 20th century far left groups were responsible for the majority of violent extremism. Wikipedia says as much as 75% [0] If you look beyond the US there are plenty of examples of left wing extremism. I point this out because it seems like you are implying that some how one ideology is inherently violent while the other is not which isn't true and that kind of thinking often leads to rationalizing bad behavior in the name of one's unassailable virtuous and noble cause. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Left-wing_terrorism#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Left-wing_terrorism#United_Sta...
- yesenadam 8y agoIn the mid 20th century far left groups were responsible for the majority of violent extremism. Wikipedia says as much as 75% Your link doesn't support what you say at all. Firstly, it's talking about terrorism just in the USA. Secondly, the 75% figure references a 1994 book[0] which is referring to "American terrorism in the eighties"[1]. To give more flavour of the book: "Had it not been for the emergence of the environmental terrorists during the closing years of the decade, terrorism in America would have been virtually non-existent during the late 1980s. ...1990...was the fourth consecutive year in which America experienced no deaths or injuries due to terrorism." Meanwhile in the 80s, the US was busy invading and subverting countries across latin America, training paramilitaries/torturers etc. But the left is the one 'rationalizing'.. [0] Brent Smith, Terrorism in America, 1994 https://archive.org/download/Terrorism_in_America_Brent_Smith/Terrorism_in_America_Brent_Smith.pdf https://archive.org/download/Terrorism_in_America_Brent_Smit... [1] "Although most Americans were left with the impression that American terrorism in the eighties was largely rightist, the actual number of acts of terrorism committed by left-wing groups accounted for about three-fourths of all officially designated acts of domestic terrorism in America." (p94)
- pmorici 8y agoYes, I and, I assumed the OP was talking about America since the statement that there aren't any leftist extremist groups is obviously untrue if you look at it from a world wide perceptive. That section on Wikipedia absolutely lists the left wing extremism that was common in America from the 1960's to the 1980's. I didn't look into the source of the stat listed there. But the point still stands, left wing extremism has existed in the US in the past even if it isn't the predominate problem present day.
- CamperBob2 8y agoThe extreme left aren't involved in mass murder at anything like the extent that the extreme right are. Communism alone makes this a difficult assertion to back up, doesn't it? Stalin made Hitler look like a Jainist. In any case, your assertion sounds like an example of what the HN mods were asking people to avoid posting.