3 ms·
I think Sean Carroll has a point: http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2009/06/17/timelessness/ http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2009/06/17/timeles
by Koshkin 8y ago
I think Sean Carroll has a point:
http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2009/06/17/timelessness/ http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2009/06/17/timeless...
- honorious 8y agoIt might not be clear from the last chapter, but the book doesn't claim that time doesn't exist. To paraphrase (but use the same example because it is funny): time doesn't appear at the fundamental concepts in physics. Cats also don't appear at the fundamental level of physics. But cats exist. Time (and our perception of it) must appear somewhere as a emergent feature.
- sixstringbudha 8y ago>but the book doesn't claim that time doesn't exist. Why are people so hung up on the question whether 'x' exist or not without actually having a proper idea of what it mean for something to "exist"?
- adrianN 8y agoIt's surpisingly hard to define what it means for something to "exist".
- foxes 8y agoTime does appear in fundamental concepts in physics? In relativity it is particularly important. Timelike dimensions are treated differently in the metric, with a +1 or -1 depending on taste, ie ds^2 = c dt^2 - dx_1^2 - dx_2^2 - dx_3^2, so I don't think its quite fair to say that it doesn't "appear". In quantum physics unitary evolution is invertible. Decoherence is not reversible (I mean interaction - loss of entanglement). Maybe these theories have been biased by our perception, but they are good (but incomplete) models.
- TomMckenny 8y agoTime in relativity bears almost no resemblance to the common definition of time. 1) There is no such thing as simultaneous. There is no universal now. 2) Time does not proceed at a constant rate 3) Time proceeds at different speeds for different observers. So time as relativity defines it is certainly true. But time as people conceive it is fundamentally different. At best, common sense time is a profoundly special case that can't imagine the general case. And at worst, a nonsensical concept evolution gave us. Perhaps so erroneous it might be valid to say it does not exist.
- FreeFull 8y agoHumans never travel at significant fractions of the speed of light with regards to other nearby things, so relativistic effects are rather hard to observe in person. It's the same how Newtonian Mechanics is a really good approximation (and still widely used, too), and because everything around us happens to obey it very closely, it is more intuitive. The difference between what Newton's equations and Einstein's equations predict for most planetary orbits is very slight.
- goldfeld 8y agoIf time is a dimension not constraining to fundamental physics, there could be higher dimensions where more fundamental things manifest, as a way to explain it, as does string theory. If there are higher dimensions, what's to say we can't actually experience more fundamental realities through consciousness traveling. If time passes slow by in an emergency or a profoundly concentrated moment, humans if definable as the human consciousness could be traveling at relativistic speeds and not knowing. Elegantly, it's not matter doing that since matter wouldn't survive the trip.
- philipov 8y agoThat all depends on how fundamental you want to be. Atomic physics used to be considered fundamental, and then we discovered something more fundamental. We've already reached the point at which reductionism breaks down in physics: you can smoothly transform between electrons and magnetic monopoles by varying the fine structure parameter, so which one is made of which? The answer is "Whichever is more convenient at the moment." [0] There are already nascent theories attempting to simplify quantum field theory, that could be considered fundamental, which are based entirely on geometric and combinatoric concepts where time isn't implicit in the definition of the theory (because it's just manipulations of polytopes) but where time emerges as a feature instead of being an assumption. [1][2] [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZ-ElsvYKyo&index=2&list=PL3E633552E58EB230 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZ-ElsvYKyo&index=2&list=PL3... [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q4Dj8fq30sk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q4Dj8fq30sk [2]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l87oICmHT2E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l87oICmHT2E
- markbnj 8y agoThanks for that link. I also think he has a point.
- baxtr 8y agoNice post! Put it this way: clearly time appears to exist, at first glance. Even the timelessness crowd somehow manages to submit their essay competition entries by the deadline, and finish their Bloggingheads dialogues within an hour.