6 ms·
I think Marvin Minsky had it right in his book The Emotion Machine (2006): From Chapter III. From Pain to Suffering >Why does the sensation called pain someti
by nabla9 8y ago
I think Marvin Minsky had it right in his book The Emotion Machine (2006):
From Chapter III. From Pain to Suffering
>Why does the sensation called pain sometimes lead to what we call suffering? How could such a simple event distort all your other thoughts so much? This chapter proposes a theory of this: if a pain is intense and persistent enough, it will stir up a certain set of resources, and then these, in turn, arouse some more. Then, if this process continues to grow, your mind becomes a victim of the kind of spreading, large-scale “cascade” that overcomes the rest of the mind, as we depicted in §1-7:
Then he quotes Daniel Dennett:
> “If you can make yourself study your pains (even quite intense pains) you will find, as it were, no room left to mind them: (they stop hurting). However studying a pain (e.g., a headache) gets boring pretty fast, and as soon as you stop studying them, they come back and hurt, which, oddly enough, is sometimes less boring than being bored by them and so, to some degree, preferable."
The whole chapter is online: http://web.media.mit.edu/~minsky/E3/eb3.html http://web.media.mit.edu/~minsky/E3/eb3.html
- kstrauser 8y agoI think so, too (even though I haven't read it). That jibes with my own experiences in meditating. Part of the process is going through a quick scan of your body and just noticing how your different parts feel: "huh, there's tenseness in my jaw", "there's a headache", "there's soreness in my leg" etc. It's amazing how quickly you can turn that from "my head hurts" to "there's pain in my head", which is a subtle but important distinction. You can't choose not to experience the pain sensation, but up to a point you can decide to simply note it and not react to it as pain.
- agumonkey 8y agoI also think that un-explained pain feels worse to one's mind. The fact that you used part of your brain to sense it changes that. I very often turn pain into a 'what are you telling me?', as if it was a form of communication. Half the time, the emotional grief vanishes.
- kstrauser 8y agoI've found that to be true for me, too. "I feel pain in my mouth. Oh, right: that's where the dentist gave me a shot. That's reasonable, then." It doesn't reduce the pain sensation, but it definitely reduces my emotional response to it. I wouldn't have believed that those were separable, but they really are. For historical reasons, I get very tense when the vehicle I'm in goes fast around curves in the road. Last week, I started to get the tell-tale panicky sensation as my bus was flying through a big bend in the highway. I thought, "huh, I'm experiencing a stress response, aren't I?" Just being consciously aware of that immediately and drastically decreased the anxiety I was feeling.
- danharaj 8y agoHah. There's definitely pain out there that can't be studied to oblivion. Anyone so pompous hasn't experienced, for example, a cluster headache.
- projektir 8y agoYeah, I am reading all these posts saying "if you just focus on the pain, it'll stop being a problem", with most examples being "my leg is sore", and wonder how much time the people have actually spent trying to imagine high pain. Comes to mind: https://xkcd.com/883/ https://xkcd.com/883/ I wonder how much this is related to poor understanding of the badness of certain situations...
- danharaj 8y agoGranted I think mindful pain management is a thing, especially chronic pain which I've had forever. But I've certainly felt acute pain far beyond the ability of my higher faculties to contend with...
- projektir 8y agoYeah, I won't disagree that things can be managed given certain conditions. There are definitely better and worse ways of greeting pain for the average person. But I'd never say it as an absolute and I think that's incredibly dangerous and the "suffering is an optional thing we invent in our heads" all over this thread is making me cringe.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ianai 8y agoI think it helps to remember that they occur as cluster headaches. It’s one thing to have a terrible pain that ends within the day. It’s quite another to have the same exact pain with maximum intensity “pounce” on you every day for weeks, months, years.
- 3pt14159 8y agoThere is a chapter in the book The Contractor by Raymond Davis, a former Special Forces soldier (allegedly) turned CIA contractor (formerly State Department) that talks about how to leave a situation in your mind when Raymond was in near-torturous conditions in a Pakistani prison. I wouldn't do it justice trying to recall it, but it's similar. You focus on the situation, understand it, then you kinda "walk away" in your mind to a place you want to go. I thought the book was much better than the reviews online made it out to be; though it is Fair Game's inferior.
- neuralzen 8y agoThat Dennett quote is fantastic...thanks!
- agumonkey 8y agoMeditating does help this. You get skilled at defusing the loop earlier. That said joy and pain is a vast topic.
- logicchains 8y agoIt reminds me of a quote by Stoic philosopher Marcus Aurelius: “If you are distressed by anything external, the pain is not due to the thing itself, but to your estimate of it; and this you have the power to revoke at any moment.”
- quadcore 8y agoSorry, language question, what does 'study' means in this context?
- tedmiston 8y agoLike observe deeply or examine