6 ms·
The actual solution is to stop manufacturing infinite plastic, and stop wrapping every single thing that is sold in throwaway plastic. The idea that we can "cl
by andrewstuart 8y ago
The actual solution is to stop manufacturing infinite plastic, and stop wrapping every single thing that is sold in throwaway plastic.
The idea that we can "clean it up" is the sort of foolish impossibility that the packaging industry / recycling industry / garbage manufacturing industry will latch on to to distract us from the real problem which is the never ending infinite unstoppable flow of garbage that they pour out every single day.
We need to stop making garbage, not try to clean up the flow that we make.
If you want to solve the "garbage world" that we now live in, start putting the blame on the packaging industry / the garbage makers.
- emtel 8y agoWell, okay, but "make the entire world stop making plastic" is not something that an individual can actually do, while "build a big ocean plastic harvester" evidently is.
- skookumchuck 8y agoPutting a tax on plastic would be a great start.
- cududa 8y agoTo reiterate the above post, that's not something an individual can do. Building an ocean skimmer is
- mreome 8y agoSo... an individual is apparently capable of constructing thousands of miles worth of marine-environment infrastructure in international waters crisscrossed by global shipping routes, managing the continuing maintenance of such infrastructure, and the logistics of collecting transportation and disposable of thousands of tons of waste... but is unable to effect political change of any kind?
- cududa 8y agoThat's absolutely something an individual can pull off. Changing international environmental policy seems way more difficult.
- mreome 8y agoThe point I was trying to make is that it isn't something that can be done as an individual, even if it works, at scale it will cost billions of dollars annually to operate, and will require the full time work of thousands of people. So pointing out that an individual can't change internally policy is a false comparison.
- cududa 8y ago$28 million to launch the first version. Raising that much money and recruiting a team is easier than influencing election outcomes in numerous (probably 100+) elections.
- jessaustin 8y agoAfter swimming (or attempting to swim, in those cases like Bacolod Philippines where the ocean was completely choked with floating trash) in the waters off various Pacific nations, I doubt that the nations who could possibly institute such a tax are the same as those who are causing this problem.
- skookumchuck 8y agoTaxing plastic would make it cost effective for manufacturers to switch to cardboard packaging. I.e. how things were packaged before 1960.
- jessaustin 8y agoA switch to cardboard packaging would be fine in nations with lots of forests like USA. It would be a calamity in e.g. India, however.
- skookumchuck 8y agoWhy? The US can't find uses for all the recycled paper after China stopped taking it.
- jessaustin 8y agoAre you suggesting that India and similarly deforested nations will decide they need paper so badly that they'll pay to ship it from USA? Rather than just cutting down the last trees they have, or (more likely) continuing to use plastic? They can't afford virtue-signaling frivolities like we can. If recycled cardboard packaging makes so much sense why are we shipping paper waste to China and anywhere else that will take it? Answer: landfills overseas aren't as embarrassing for "recycling" programs as landfills in the same county. Personally I have nothing against paper/cardboard packaging. However, I note that people in USA have chosen plastic packaging for many applications. We can assume that the same reasons that motivate us, also motivate others. They also have other issues, like poverty. More regressive taxes on these populations will lead to more children dying of starvation. As another comment noted, the way to actually fix the plastic pollution problem (distinct from the plastic cleanup problem that TFA targets) is to identify the watersheds that produce 95% of the plastic, and then help them set up modern garbage handling at price points that those people can actually afford to use. They are very poor, which is why they're polluting in the first place. Also many of these watersheds are islands with few suitable landfill locations. Instead of talking about silly things like laws that should be passed in other nations, let's talk about how much aid will be required to actually fix this problem.
- cultus 8y agoIt's not though. The ocean is big, it is violent. This won't work. https://www.kcet.org/redefine/6-reasons-that-floating-ocean-plastic-cleanup-gizmo-is-a-horrible-idea https://www.kcet.org/redefine/6-reasons-that-floating-ocean-...
- mreome 8y agoThe problem is your assuming "build a big ocean plastic harvester" is a totally valid solution that won't potentially add to the problem. Just because it's something an individual can do, doesn't mean it's good idea. How much will it hurt the ecosystem it's supposed help? Who is going maintain it? Who is going to recover it when it is torn apart in a storm?
- acranox 8y ago"We need to stop making garbage, not try to clean up the flow that we make." We need both actually. Stopping the manufacture of junk plastic will not cause the oceans to become cleaner. It will just stop them from getting worse. But in order to make the oceans cleaner, you need to actually remove the pollution that is in them. Hence, we need to do both.
- mreome 8y agoPlastic does decompose, quite a bit faster in the ocean then it does in a landfill actually. That is why so much of the plastic is already broken down into very tiny particles. If we could stop any new plastics from entering the ocean, it would very slowly begin to clean itself.
- Baeocystin 8y agoThe vast majority of plastic waste in the oceans come from just a handful of rivers that pass through countries that don't have garbage collection available as a society-wide service. Investing in waste management infrastructure in the communities that live along the riverbanks would reap an immediate benefit to the people so affected, and stop pollution at the source.