4 ms·
We already have a distributed backup system: the keyserver network. There are also efforts like DANE to put it in DNS. They however refuse to sync with it. They
by lrvick 8y ago
We already have a distributed backup system: the keyserver network. There are also efforts like DANE to put it in DNS. They however refuse to sync with it. They only sync with their own proprietary servers using their own protocol.
Also there are projects in the OpenPGP world making very easy to use workflows and interfaces without centralizing or breaking standards. OpenKeychain for android is a fantastic example of this.
I use OpenKeychain on my phone and can sign files, access passwords, or decrypt email by tapping my yubikey to it. I can tap someone elses key to my phone to import their key to my addressbook. No terminals or fuss and at no point does any key come in contact with system memory of any device involved so I have strong assurances it can't be stolen even if my phone is totally compromised.
A big example of the 2 steps backwards of keybase: they use keys in system memory and abandoned any compatibility with the openpgp smartcard spec, yubikeys, etc. The industry is moving to smartcards for very good reason: malware is a thing and it can use/steal keys from system memory without user interaction. A key stored in a yubikey 4 OTOH never touches system memory and requires a physical touch for each operation.
You can have usability without throwing out security and standards. Keybase is just another in a long line of companies ignorantly throwing out any security features they don't understand using usability as an excuse for bad engineering.
- Leace 8y ago> There are also efforts like DANE to put it in DNS. It seems GnuPG and "the ecosystem" is slowly moving to WKD (Web Key Directory) as it is easier to deploy (e.g. kernel.org is using it). If you put your binary key (gpg --export 36C8AAA9) at https://lrvick.net/.well-known/openpgpkey/hu/gfoh5t79df9raqtiz8f6gsg8urexr9wo https://lrvick.net/.well-known/openpgpkey/hu/gfoh5t79df9raqt... tools would retrieve it automatically when using your e-mail address (gpg --locate-key $EMAIL). (I got the hash by running gpg -k --with-wkd 36C8AAA9). This is supported by GnuPG, OpenKeychain and some e-mail clients: Enigmail, GpgOL (Outlook) would fetch your key in background when someone is writing an e-mail. For details see: https://wiki.gnupg.org/WKD#Implementations https://wiki.gnupg.org/WKD#Implementations The spec: https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-koch-openpgp-webkey-service/ https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-koch-openpgp-webkey-s...