6 ms·
I frequently see recommendations to disable "safe browsing" features. Why?
by nerdponx 8y ago
I frequently see recommendations to disable "safe browsing" features. Why?
- dao- 8y agoHysteria or ignorance, as with other items in this list. Safe browsing is designed not to compromise privacy.
- gsnedders 8y agoNotably, the Safe Browsing Update API never sends the URL itself to the server: it does a local lookup with hash prefixes of the URL, and only if that finds some threat does it then send the hash prefix to Google (which gives some degree of deniability, given they never know what actual URL you've visited, and only rarely get anything).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hnaccy 8y agoMaybe I just don't want to send Google any info.
- nerdponx 8y agoWhat other items do you think fall into this category?
- dao- 8y agoFor instance, disabling geolocation. You need to explicitly approve geolocation requests anyway. If you're sure you'll never ever want to share your location with a site, sure, disable it globally. But recommending this to others as a way to protect their privacy is a bit silly.
- Drdrdrq 8y agoWell, I for one appreciate the recommendation and will follow it to get rid of annoying messages. To each their own.
- Drdrdrq 8y agoHa! Says Google, right? Anything that gets sent to them is too much.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kahnpro 8y agoBecause those features can involve uploading your browsing history to 3rd parties... does Microsoft check locally against malicious site lists, or does it upload every address you visit in order to tell you it's safe?
- gsnedders 8y agoI'm unaware of any anti-malware/phishing tool that uploads every address, because it'd be far too slow (you want to know if it's malicious before you show the user anything, to avoid them having the chance to interact with it). They all have some local partial list that is used for a first match, and only if that matches do they interact with any online service. MS don't have a publicly documented API, which makes it harder to know what's being sent (short of reverse-engineering it), but Google's never uploads actual addresses (it almost always only uploads the uppermost 32-bits of the SHA256 hash of the address, and it never uploads the full hash).
- Uh7seidu 8y agoIt blocks legitimate sites, e.g. file-droppers just because someone dropped a malware file there.
- dao- 8y agoWhich even if true has nothing to do with privacy...