4 ms·
Meanwhile, established car makers are twiddling their thumbs and paying their lobbyists to delay the phase out of internal combustion engines for as long as pos
by adrianN 8y ago
Meanwhile, established car makers are twiddling their thumbs and paying their lobbyists to delay the phase out of internal combustion engines for as long as possible.
In Germany the Deutsche Umwelthilfe has to literally sue ever city separately to force their hands to do something about pollution. Bavaria simply ignores the court orders. Efforts to improve bikeability and public transport plan on multi decade timelines. Here in Berlin there are plans to extend the subway that are older than I am and are still being discussed. Electric busses are somehow not suitable for cities outside of China, we're still "evaluating options".
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoIt's starting to look like, in an effort to democratise democracy, what we're actually doing is turning everything in to bikeshedding. In an effort to be all-inclusive, and generally not upset anyone, we're getting almost nothing done while China just steams ahead. I'm probably being a bit hyperbolic, but you get the idea. While we're all enraptured by the tomfoolery of our political "leaders", China is building. Who knows if it'll all work out, but you can't blame them for trying. Whereas you can certainly blame us for being paralysed.
- pasabagi 8y agoI think democracy isn't really an engineering project - it's a communications medium. So while it seems slow and full of bikeshedding, that's because if you don't work out everything procedurally, people turn to other channels. The chinese are really conscious of this - it's why they are investing so heavily in reducing corruption, which is the archetypal sign of people 'working around' the system. It's possible that with new technology, they'll succeed - but traditionally, non-democratic projects don't work out because the official channels are useless, and the center doesn't know what the periphery is doing. People will behave as long as the economy is growing, but as soon as it contracts, everybody will start turning to crime or politics.
- doombolt 8y ago> they are investing so heavily in reducing corruption I am extremely sceptical about such claims. Claiming to fight corruption is usually more of PR stunt. To really fight corruption you have to do institutionalized changes, such as increasing transparency, which is painful for most of regimes on Earth. Fighting corruption without changing the system is busy work and reality show.
- pasabagi 8y agoI'm actually pretty convinced. I think the Party is basically fairly smart, and they are extremely aware of the threats to their rule. For instance, after the first gulf war, they started extensive military reforms, presumably seeing how Saddam's gigantic, tank-heavy, cold-war era army fared against new technology, and seeing that the same could happen to them. I think time and time again, they've moved very fast to neutralize threats - and as I see it, there are few that would be more pressing than general disillusionment, the normalization of graft and cynicism. It's this culture that really killed the USSR. When nobody believes in your system, it doesn't matter how absolute your power is, or how utterly defeated your enemies are. Everybody in your administration will be essentially working for themselves, and stealing everything that isn't bolted down.
- doombolt 8y agoI'm really unconvinced by Xi Jinping concentrating power. It does look like he desperately wants to be China's Putin (with the charisma of Medvedev), and there's nobody to stop him.
- pasabagi 8y agoYeah, that's probably a bad sign. That said, I don't think it's as fundamental a difference as a western perspective makes it out to be. Westerners are, for obvious reasons, terrified of charismatic leaders - but there are plenty of dictatorships that get along just fine with a bureacracy. Having an official great leader doesn't necessarily transform the power structure.
- NTDF9 8y ago> It's starting to look like, in an effort to democratise democracy, what we're actually doing is turning everything in to bikeshedding. No. The problem is lobbying to keep vested interests intact. Lobbying is fundamentally, "More money = more voice". Western democracies have become corrupt all the way to the top with lobbying, stifling growth, ingenuity and engineering
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoYes, that’s a very good point. I think we can have both: lobbying at a macro level, and bikeshedding locally. Or some blend of.
- anjc 8y ago> Meanwhile, established car makers are twiddling their thumbs and paying their lobbyists to delay the phase out of internal combustion engines for as long as possible. Why wouldn't they? Why should a government have the power to end a legitimate industry, which contributes massively to GDP and society's well-being, without a long changeover process?
- adrianN 8y agoBecause the climate is fucked, the air quality in cities is bad and the companies literally cheat on emission tests. The changeover process should have started in the eighties. It's much too late now for a slow change. And btw, the car industry could have taken the lead in the development of alternative engines instead of optimizing for next-quarter profits.
- dexen 8y ago>the air quality in cities is bad I'm all for reducing emissions. Having said that, let's be frank about air quality having improved immensely over recent decades. Back before the (ICE and electric) cars became a thing, the inner city air and rivers were much more heavily polluted, by coal & wood heating, and outflow of untreated sewage. It's only thanks to significant surplus, provided by high efficiency, in turn provided by modern technology & science - including transportation - that we can invest heavily into actively (scrubbers) and passively (more involved, but cleaner processes) reducing pollution. So yes, we want to reduce emissions, eventually doing away with most, or all, ICE and other oil consumers. But the technology necessary, and the required economic surplus, is pretty much provided and accelerated by the cheap and portable energy generators in cars and others, fueled & lubricated by petrol and other fossil fuels. Ditto smaller, lighter products made of plastics and other materials we currently manufacture partly off of crude oil. Path dependence, let's consider the whole picture.
- bildung 8y agoGermany started this changeover process decades ago, those companies just use corruption to have the cake and eat it, too.
- choeger 8y agoThe DUH makes shitloads of money by side-stepping elected bodies to enforce policies that are highly symbolic and known to change exactly nothing. Next step will be Otto engines, then EVs, then ...? The actual cause is that currently Everyone has to move to the big cities I'd imagine lots of Berlin Hipsters would not be so complacent once the DUH sues them because their Altbauwohnung wastes precious space and energy and pollutes the city air.
- adrianN 8y agoThe actual cause is having too many cars in cities. This trend has been obvious since the nineties at least. Why didn't the government act to reduce the need of cars in cities? Nobody likes bans for Diesels, but the people responsible sat on their hands instead of implementing plans that don't disproportionally affect poorer people who drive older cars.
- talltimtom 8y agoNot as long as possible. Just long enough for them to secure a position on the electric hybrid market.