7 ms·
If you turn 65 in 2040 or 2050 or 2060 Some historical perspective: My understanding is that when Social Security was created, the average life expectancy was
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
If you turn 65 in 2040 or 2050 or 2060
Some historical perspective: My understanding is that when Social Security was created, the average life expectancy was 67. So offering it for people age 65 was intended as providing for people in extreme old age who had probably worked physically hard their entire lives and were pretty beat up.
I'm not saying we don't have genuine problems here, but this article is bellyaching about, basically, a golden era when the world was relatively briefly unusually comfortable and acting like that was the norm throughout all of history. The reality is that money per se only became common place something like 300 years or so ago. So the very concept of retirement and saving for retirement is relatively new.
This makes it a little hard for me to take this article seriously, so I confess to not reading it in full. Some of the things it gets right: Pensions are going out of style precisely because people are living longer, so pensions wind up being financially unsustainable.
Given that people are living a whole lot longer and are generally in better health at 70 these days than 65 used to be, it isn't really some huge hand-wringing drama that older Americans need to continue working. Instead, it is evidence of how successful we have been in some sense.
This is a good problem to have. We need to make adjustments to the system, but people living longer and this requiring cultural adjustments isn't some giant tragedy.
Retirement for, say, two decades or whatever is hardly some historical and long standing human norm. It's really rather out of touch with reality to act like it ever was.
- tkjef 8y agoThanks for the perspective. It does help to not feel like we're missing out on something due to us.
- fomojola 8y agoThis is not emphasized enough: prior to the last 100 years, the concept of retirement as currently visualized simply did not exist. You had kids, and the kids took care of you in your old age (or you just had a terrible old age). A very small number of people had the resource base to survive growing old gracefully: Social Security was an attempt to extend that to all on a consistent basis. That's not to say some form of it can't be made to work, but as much as we may love the core concept of retirement we may need to accept that it isn't broadly economically viable without a meaningful, direct index against increasing life expectancy (with the usual caveats for infirmity, disease, etc). It is (in my opinion) a well meaning, long term social experiment that might be coming to an end. I am quite curious to see what (and how) we get to the other side of that.
- ryandrake 8y agoI’m curious too. What’s the solution? Life expectancy keeps going up, but the age at which our bodies can no longer work has stayed relatively flat. People are living long past when they can no longer work. Fact. Society needs to solve this or we risk letting the elderly starve on the street.
- mmirate 8y agoIf someone is unproductive and can't/won't work, then people shouldn't be obligated to give him/her the fruits of their labor.
- ryandrake 8y agoI hope you don’t suddenly become disabled or chronically ill without a support network, with that attitude.
- mmirate 8y ago> disabled or chronically ill a priori, I consider both of those fates worse than death. Support network or no.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoYou probably won't get anyone to engage you in earnest. I have a genetic disorder. I'm significantly impacted by it. I spend part of every single day wishing I were dead and I'm actually pro Right to Die. But your sweeping pronouncements are hard to engage because your first one isn't about your personal preference to die if faced with certain things. It's a pronouncement about not supporting others. I fully support your right to choose to die rather than live with certain things, but it's much more complicated when we start talking about making general policies. At that point, you really need to provide some support for people who have had something unfortunate happen because society just works better when you do. Trying to decide who, what, when, where and how much gets tricky. But a society that throws people to the wolves if they are even temporarily impaired winds up actively creating more problems than it solves. You are lumping together your personal preference to die rather than live with X into your desire to not do shit all for other people and that makes it really hard to have a meaningful discussion here.
- simonsarris 8y agoWell, the life expectancy at birth was 67 because of lots of early deaths. Life expectancy at 65 has only increased by 2 or 3 years: https://www.seniorliving.org/history/1900-2000-changes-life-expectancy-united-states/ https://www.seniorliving.org/history/1900-2000-changes-life-... Once you're old, you've kinda "made it" as far as life expectancy numbers go. I think someone who is 70 in 1935 would be considered just as "old aged" as someone 70 today. In fact someone who made it to 70 in the early 1900's may be considered healthier due to obesity/diabetes epidemic numbers alone...
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThe article you linked to doesn't seem to fit with your claims and I don't believe your claim is accurate. Everything I have seen indicates we are seeing a lot more people live into their 80s and beyond. I'm not going to try to prove that. My understanding is that is common knowledge.
- EADGBE 8y ago(This isn't entirely a reply to you, my apologies) https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/SPDYNLE00INUSA https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/SPDYNLE00INUSA graphs out life expectancy for the US since 1960. I couldn't find a source where it went back to 1935 as well. According to the World Bank, we're averaging about 78 right now. So, with the same assumptions made in 1935, we should be working until we're about 76; a full 11 more years of contributions before withdrawal. Some will live longer, some won't make it. Life sucks. (Aside: who will actively employ septuagenarians?) Combine that same thought with the idea of the maximum taxable limit ($128,400) and the "demise of SS" would probably be a lot less of a real threat. Then again, in its inception, it only taxed from the first $3,000[1] wage earned (~$55,000 in today's money). [1] https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/policybriefs/pb2011-02.html https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/policybriefs/pb2011-02.html
- microtherion 8y agoSome historical perspective: My understanding is that when Social Security was created, the average life expectancy was 67. While this is true, I think it's a misleading statistic. The relevant figure, it seems to me, is not life expectancy at birth, but life expectancy at age 65 (because the latter determines social security outlay). In the 1930s, a 65 year old could expect to live for about 12 more years, while in 2010, life expectancy was about 18 years. That's a considerably smaller increase than life expectancy at birth during that time. https://www.ssa.gov/oact/NOTES/as116/as116_V.html https://www.ssa.gov/oact/NOTES/as116/as116_V.html
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI will note that my framing comes directly from something I saw somewhere. So my understanding is that it was intended a certain way. There's a great book called How to lie with statistics. It makes a lot of excellent points about how framing the same data differently can support different conclusions. So, some thoughts: Law makers who passed it may not have realized the average 65 year old would live another 12 years. They may have only known average life expectancy was 67. Six years longer may not sound like much, but it's 50 percent longer. That can have significant repercussions.
- microtherion 8y agoLaw makers who passed it may not have realized the average 65 year old would live another 12 years. Interesting theory, but that mistake should have become evident by the late 1940s and led to a lot of debate, and I am not aware that there was one. Six years longer may not sound like much, but it's 50 percent longer. And labor productivity has more than doubled during that time, so society should be in a vastly better position to afford social security. I think it's important to see past the framing of economic inevitability and realize that there is simply a well organized political movement that does not WANT there to be retirement security for the general population, and because that's not really a popular political goal, the framing is instead that social security is unaffordable.
- 8y ago