47 ms·
Some insults are simply worse depending on who they are targeting. It is the difference between calling GW Bush a monkey because he occasionally looked like a
by slg 8y ago
Some insults are simply worse depending on who they are targeting. It is the difference between calling GW Bush a monkey because he occasionally looked like a monkey and Obama being called a monkey as a racial slur. The former is a childish insult that is easy to ignore. The latter is a form of bigotry that shouldn't be tolerated.
- ziroshima 8y agoGauging the degree to which insults are insulting or offensive (based on context!) is always going to be problematic. I find your comment a little bit disturbing because it reminds me of the Roseanne fiasco. The woman she was insulting really does look like she could have been in the planet of the apes films. Is it racist to publicly observe a similar appearance? If someone believes that Obama has a monkey-like appearance, as you believe GW Bush does, are they racist? In other words, intent is often not the same as the interpretation, which as long as we are doing trial by public opinion, I am not comfortable with.
- slg 8y agoThe person calling a black person a monkey or a Jewish person a rat is either ignorant of the history of those slurs or they aren't. If they are ignorant of that history, they can easily be excused. The ignorance is usually obvious based on their history of behavior because the accusation would likely be an isolated incident. Considering the history of accusations against Jones and Roseanne, I am pretty confident in saying they are both aware of how their words could be interpreted. If that person is aware of the history of using those comparisons and isn't racist, what is the reasoning is still using that specific language? You can call Obama any number of insults and not be called a racist. Why would you choose an insult that you know will draw racial comparisons?
- noobermin 8y agoContext is important, as is learning history.
- ryanobjc 8y agoPower dynamics are real, and the legal system deals with context all the time. So do humans, they handle it quite well in fact (hence why our languages are not context-free). I know computer people want consistency in rules. However, do you want to have a simple-minded consistency (with full invocation of Emerson intended here), or do you value full inclusion and reparative actions to restore full humanity to everyone who shares your DNA, yet were considered non-human in the past? (and still are by many people, who are actively attempting to return the past to the future.) Slavery is ugly and MOST people don't love thinking about that era. Some people DO love thinking about it, and are actively attempting to bring it back. To quote a choose your own adventure: - If you want to turn your back on historical realities, turn to page 55 - If you embrace the uncomfortable and pledge to work for the betterment of all, turn to page 100
- ArchTypical 8y ago> Some insults are simply worse depending on who they are targeting. That's just an ideological step that is unwise to adopt. Taking that as a philosophy, anything you say is an intolerable statement because of who might get offended by it. This is antithetical to free speech as prior restraint. I don't know why anyone would subscribe to such a viewpoint. Every philosophy has boons and banes, but that doesn't mean the philosophy is absolute nor moral.
- happytoexplain 8y agoI think the position you're addressing is actually a practical one. Context is huge in communication, and who is being addressed is a big part of that context. It's hard for me to believe that you actually think that taking that specific context into account leads to the conclusion that all statements are intolerable.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoNo, the unwise thing is to ignore context and history. "This is antithetical to free speech as prior restraint" No, it isn't. Free Speech doesn't mean you get to ignore context, and it doesn't mean you don't face consequences for your speech.
- rhcom2 8y ago> anything you say is an intolerable statement because of who might get offended by it. That isn't what OP said though. I believe they were commenting that all words are not the same to every group of people and cultural and historical context matters.
- slg 8y agoExactly. It has nothing to do with who might be offended. It has to do with a history of racial oppression. No one is going to complain if you compare a individual black person to a rat or an individual Jewish person to a monkey because there is no historical precedent of those insults being used as blanket attacks against those groups. It is when you flip those two that you will get in trouble.
- deleted 8y ago
- assblaster 8y agoWhy is making fun of Obama as a monkey any different than with Bush? Why is it racist? Obama is white, Bush is white. They both have big ears. Similarly, Trump is mocked as an orangutan. Is that racist against his European heritage (red/orange hair of Irish/Scottish/German)?