5 ms·
There are times that I wished I was a Catholic so I could condemn types like this - and mr. McBride - to hell. FYI, we're specifically enjoined against doing t
by patio11 16y ago
There are times that I wished I was a Catholic so I could condemn types like this - and mr. McBride - to hell.
FYI, we're specifically enjoined against doing that. Final disposition of all souls is up to God. (We think we know roughly what he is looking for because He told us a few times and we can reason through the rest, but the list of people for whom final dispositions are known is really short -- off the top of my head, saints, martyrs, and baptized infants who die prior to reaching the age where they can be held morally responsible for sin can be safely declared to be in heaven, and that list is exclusive. Many people are under the misapprehension that suicide is an auto-fail. This is not the case: quoting the Catechism, "We should not despair of the eternal salvation of persons who have taken their own lives. By ways known to him alone, God can provide the opportunity for salutary repentance. The Church prays for persons who have taken their own lives.")
Returning you now to your regularly scheduled topics of interest to hackers.
- pavs 16y agoWhat? Are you serious?
- patio11 16y agoI'm confused as to the reaction to this post. Someone made an offhanded remark about something they think that Catholics do: condemning people to hell. We don't do that. It is important that we don't do that, both internally (salvation is kind of a hot topic in theology) and externally (i.e. anyone with the understanding that Catholics are routinely saying "X is going to hell" is likely to have a poor opinion of us, based off of misinformed prejudice). So I tried replying with the thumbnail sketch of what the Church actually teaches regarding this.
- mbateman 16y agoIs this a modern thing? Pope Pius IX is famous for anathematizing people who advocated the freedom of religious worship.
- joshuacc 16y agoAnathematizing a person isn't the same thing as condemning a person to hell. Rather it is a form of excommunication (prohibition from receiving communion). The ultimate fate of the person in question is understood to be in God's hands.
- mbateman 16y agoTo answer my own question, yes, it's a modern thing. Here's the original ritual of anathematizing: "Wherefore in the name of God the All-powerful, Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, of Blessed Peter, Prince of the Apostles, and of all the saints, in virtue of the power which has been given us of binding and loosing in Heaven and on earth, we deprive (Name) himself and all his accomplices and all his abettors of the Communion of the Body and Blood of Our Lord, we separate him from the society of all Christians, we exclude him from the bosom of our Holy Mother the Church in Heaven and on earth, we declare him excommunicated and anathematized and we judge him condemned to eternal fire with Satan and his angels and all the reprobate, so long as he will not burst the fetters of the demon, do penance and satisfy the Church; we deliver him to Satan to mortify his body, that his soul may be saved on the day of judgment." Looks like this was changed to exclude the hell bit in 1917. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anathema#Catholic_Church http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anathema#Catholic_Church
- pavs 16y agoOk, I think I know what happened here. Overwhelming large number of HNers are atheists (according to recent polls), including me. But that alone should not be a reason to downvote a comment about religious beliefs, just because we don't agree with that (or any) religious beliefs. My first impression from reading your comment was that your were portraying your religious beliefs as universal facts. Maybe my initial interpretation and reaction was wrong, but thats how I saw it. After reading your second comment and going back and reading the previous comment again I can see why you got the downvotes for expressing your (catholic) religious views. I think it would have been better if you have said "According to catholic belief" instead of "We". Anyways, nothing personal. As a former very religious Muslim, I can understand where you are coming from.
- joshuacc 16y agoIn context it seems very clear that he meant "We Catholics."
- akadien 16y agoOf course you can't condemn anyone to hell because there is no such thing as hell.
- iron_ball 16y agoSpoken like a man who has never made a Javascript webapp work in IE6.
- Dove 16y agoThere is a certain crowd of atheists that believe religion--any religion--is not merely incorrect but is actually transparently irrational. Notionally, that if a religious person would just take an afternoon and think carefully over what he knows, he must either (A) become an atheist or (B) be quite intellectually dishonest or (C) not be very smart. It naturally follows that atheists are inherently smarter or at least more honest than religious folks of any stripe. So when someone from this crowd comes across a religious person who is plainly intelligent, who indeed they look up to, who clearly cares and thinks about religious things . . . well, the result is generally some sort of spit-take. I see it once or twice a month at least. I expect some folks are a bit shell-shocked that the great patio11 also claims to be Catholic.
- loewenskind 16y agoSo bigots are surprised to find out that their ignorance-based beliefs don't always hold? :)
- cubix 16y agoI'm an atheist and think it is transparently irrational, however, not to those afflicted by the more virulent forms of religion from early childhood. I would expect completely freeing oneself from the effects of such an upbringing would take years, if not a lifetime, and come at considerable cost to one's friends and familial relationships. You would have to be callous and remarkably ignorant of human psychology to think it could be overcome in an afternoon of contemplation. I've known many smart but religious people, so I'm not terribly shocked. However, I'm yet to encounter -- and doubtful I ever will -- an intelligent person, raised in a healthy, secure and atheistic home, who as an adult earnestly embraced some established religion like Catholicism.
- eru 16y agoHere's an anecdote: A friend of mine, a girl who studied mathematics with me, got herself christened when she was around 20. Her parents aren't in any church. She grew up in atheist East Germany. It's seems quite rare for adults to change their religion, though.
- 16y ago
- jacquesm 16y agoNot all Catholics are good Catholics in their interpretation of scripture (that's why they have priests ;) ) and even though you are enjoined against doing that I'm sure it's been done before. As for the downvotes, I think your little lecture is setting up some serious cognitive dissonance in peoples heads along the lines of them being unable to cope with being an obviously very smart guy that is also very religious. As if the one should automatically make it impossible to be the other. I have to consciously remind myself not to fall in to that trap and to recognize that my atheism is as much a result of indoctrination as your Catholicism probably is. I think you're pretty brave for wearing that religious badge so openly in a place that is clearly biased towards the atheist walk of life, and filled with people who tend to see someones religion as an accident of birth rather than one that was arrived at by the scientific method or the choice of a free will but by indoctrination instead.
- gort 16y agoHe means he wishes he believed in Hell, so he could believe patent trolls went there.