4 ms·
> So, the strongest and most common objection against the English rule is that it would prevent the poor from suing even if they had a good case; they just coul
by Silhouette 16y ago
> So, the strongest and most common objection against the English rule is that it would prevent the poor from suing even if they had a good case; they just couldn't afford a 10% chance of owing thousands of dollars. I am very sympathetic to this objection.
That is very unlikely. Courts are not generally required to award costs to the winner of a case here in England, it is more of a default in most cases instead of adopting "everyone pays their own costs" as in the US.
I am not a legal expert, but I doubt a court would award crippling costs to a little guy who brought a case with genuine merit against a big guy but lost, where the little guy incurred only modest costs but the big guy brought the whole legal team to bear.
Likewise, I doubt a big guy bringing a punitive law suit against a little guy and incurring lots of costs when they could have settled things in another less expensive way would get much sympathy, which is why the US seems to have certain Big Media organisings effectively extorting settlements from innocent people for thousands of dollars, while such behaviour is unheard of in this country.
> Already, lawyers will offer to work for free unless the plaintiff wins.
I guess you're referring to so-called "no win, no fee" agreements? If so, it's not quite as simple as that (the lawyers also stand to gain more if they win than they would in a regular case), but your general argument still works.
- jessriedel 16y ago>Courts are not generally required to award costs to the winner of a case here in England, it is more of a default in most cases instead of adopting "everyone pays their own costs" as in the US. Thanks, I didn't know this. I'm still not convinced that the threat of legal fees wouldn't convince a non-insignificant fraction of poor plaintiffs not to sue. > I guess you're referring to so-called "no win, no fee" agreements? If so, it's not quite as simple as that (the lawyers also stand to gain more if they win than they would in a regular case)... I know. In effect, the lawyer is selling insurance to the client. The client will get less in case of a win both because (a) he bought insurance, which brings his variance down (and so, his total payout in case of a win is lower) and (b) the lawyer collects a premium for absorbing the risk.
- irons 16y agoI am not a legal expert, but I doubt a court would award crippling costs to a little guy who brought a case with genuine merit against a big guy but lost, where the little guy incurred only modest costs but the big guy brought the whole legal team to bear. That's a whole lot of conditionals. In places where the judiciary is thoroughly corrupted by electioneering (coal interests in West Virginia, for instance), relying on judges to respond non-punitively can be an unsafe assumption already. A libertarian loser-pays movement only slants that further.
- msbarnett 16y agoIndeed, which suggests that in order to move towards the less acrimonious legal atmosphere of the UK or Europe, you would need to do more than adopt some of their mechanics. You'd ultimately need to de-politicize the entire branch of government. As far as I know, in the UK and most of Europe, and definitely here in Canada, Judges are appointed by judicial commissions on the basis of strength of legal scholarship, not picked in a popular election based on who can raise the most money and pander to the right interest groups.
- irons 16y agoBeyond de-politicization, which can cut a lot of different ways, the other factor in acrimony-reduction is the European social safety net. The EU legal system doesn't have to be the tool of last resort to the same extent as in the American style. See also Matt Yglesias: http://yglesias.thinkprogress.org/2008/12/loser_pays/ http://yglesias.thinkprogress.org/2008/12/loser_pays/
- Silhouette 16y agoWhat do you mean by the "European social safety net"? The legal system should normally be the last resort, but you seem to be suggesting that we have some sort of universal alternative to try first. There may be other options in specific contexts, for example disputes with service providers in regulated industries where there is some sort of ombudsman scheme, but it is not the case in general.
- 16y ago