5 ms·
AFAICT, many jackpot style lotteries get an expected value (EV) above 1 when the jackpots get big. They're set up so their average EV is 0.4 - 0.5, but when a
by bryanlarsen 8y ago
AFAICT, many jackpot style lotteries get an expected value (EV) above 1 when the jackpots get big. They're set up so their average EV is 0.4 - 0.5, but when a jackpot isn't won, the payout is under 0.1. String a bunch of those together in a row, and the EV creeps above 1.0.
The calculations are easy to do. You do need to estimate the number of people who buy the tickets so you can calculate the odds of sharing the jackpot. The real number isn't publicly available, but newspapers often have numbers for similar jackpots in the past.
As the article mentions, lotteries protect themselves by making it logistically impossible for anybody to buy every ticket.
Here's the calculation for Canada's Lotto 6/49 in 2007: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1vHOOdmobb3729ezH1BnOSZBGfmcF0rzQvgM18EVGOyo/edit?usp=sharing https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1vHOOdmobb3729ezH1BnO...
- eximius 8y agoWhile true, expected value isn't necessarily a useful metric at that point. If I have a one in a googol chance of winning a googolplex dollars, it doesn't really matter that the expected value is going to be huge, I still won't win anything because I'll be insolvent before the requisite number of tries to have a reasonable chance of winning.
- solotronics 8y agothats why the people who do this work as a company and pool their resources
- grkvlt 8y agoIt's more that the people who do this do more than just buying a single ticket with positive expected value - as described in the article.
- tunesmith 8y agoYeah, the Kelly Criterion is a good thing to explore in situations like this. If there's (truly) positive EV, you still should only spend a certain percentage of your bankroll on the bet. And if the bet has high payoff and low odds, your bankroll likely has to be astronomical in order for the bet to be a good decision.
- grkvlt 8y agoTrue, +EV is useless if the variance is huge, as is the case with lotteries.
- lev99 8y agoYour EV numbers are high. If the EV was really significantly above 1.0 (say 1.5) then everyone would buy a lot of lotto tickets. It would be simple arbitrage. In reality all of those people buying extra tickets (because of the high perceived EV) would mean a higher chance of splitting the pot. Splitting the pot would reduce the real return by 1/2 for every person that purchased a ticket.
- astrodust 8y agoSometimes the EV goes above 1.0 and there are several groups of people who closely monitor lotteries all over the US to spot this event. When it does happen, which is very rare, they do calculations on the expected impact, viability and if their conclusions are good, swoop in and buy hundreds of thousands of tickets. They have people printing tickets for an entire day. They pay stores to stay open late. It's a tactical operation. Sometimes the jackpot is so anomalously big that the general public can't buy enough tickets to bring it back down below 1.0.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- delecti 8y agoThe post you replied to seem to imply a "naive EV", because they already discussed odds of sharing the jackpot.
- bryanlarsen 8y agoThe odds of splitting the pot are calculated in my spreadsheet. In the first scenario, that decreases the EV from 2.15 to 1.11.
- femto113 8y agoProblem with this calculation it it assumes that exactly one person/group undertakes the buy-every-ticket strategy. As soon as there are two or more groups the chances of splitting the pot goes to 100%.
- dfxm12 8y agoAs the article mentions, lotteries protect themselves by making it logistically impossible for anybody to buy every ticket. I wonder why they care. In fact, they need someone to win big, so as to entice future players...
- xyzzyz 8y agoBut someone will win big, sooner or later. It is more enticing that a random lucky person wins rather than a syndicate.
- moate 8y agoBecause knowing that you're competing against large, well funded organizations on a regular basis makes people suddenly start to realize (to a small degree) how statistics work. If you assume that everyone else has the same basic odds of winning that you do (1 in a Million for example) you might play. But if you find out that you have a 1:1,000,000 chance and another well funded group has a 1:10 chance, you're going to quickly realize you're just throwing away money. If an unfair game is equally unfair for everyone, it's fair. If it's only unfair for some/most people to a greater degree than some other people, then it's unfair.
- mark-r 8y agoI track the EV of 5 different lotteries available in Minnesota. At this moment only one of them is over 0.5, at 0.55. I don't even think about buying a ticket until it gets over 0.8.
- dagenix 8y agoI'm not sure that is really logical. The odds of winning are the same regardless of if it $400m you can win or $20m. However, the effect on your life would be basically the same in either case. To be fair, I do much the same thing. But, it doesn't really have a basis in logic. It's all psychological.
- zwaps 8y agoy'all really need to read this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St._Petersburg_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St._Petersburg_paradox
- GFischer 8y agoVery interesting.
- paulie_a 8y agoThe funny thing is you don't need any stats to win smaller amounts of money. Just the simple question "hey what's the newest 10 dollar ticket" was enough to result in a solid net positive and a lot of beer money in college. They tended to front load the winning tickets for the newest ones.
- zone411 8y agoOne significant difference compared to the U.S. jackpots - you need to pay taxes, unlike in Canada.