4 ms·
> I question the "devoted to peace" part. They were devoted to expanding Islam by force, and peace after they had conquered you Also known as an empire. >Isla
by boomboomsubban 8y ago
> I question the "devoted to peace" part. They were devoted to expanding Islam by force, and peace after they had conquered you
Also known as an empire.
>Islam fought maybe ten times more battles to expand than the Crusades fought against Islam.
What a strange comparison. Without seeing the details, it seems to be comparing the battles sanctioned by the Pope during a few centuries against any expansion battle by any Islamic state over a period greater than a millennium. If it is the video linked, that seems like an accurate description. It doesn't even show the Christian expansion into Spain.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- AnimalMuppet 8y ago> Also known as an empire. That still doesn't make them devoted to peace, though.
- boomboomsubban 8y agoIt makes them as devoted to peace as other's in similar positions. Sometimes they advocated peace, other times they engaged in war. Trying to paint them as uniquely expansionist is the problem.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoI wasn't trying to paint them as uniquely expansionist. I was (rather clearly, I thought) questioning that they were devoted to peace. They weren't.
- boomboomsubban 8y agoThen why bring up that seemingly incredibly biased comparison you saw? That's what's unclear about your post.
- flukus 8y ago> Then why bring up that seemingly incredibly biased comparison you saw? To compare it to a baseline of something universally regarded as "not peaceful". Assuming you agree that the crusades weren't peaceful then you can't really claim that islamic expansion was peaceful can you? > Without seeing the details, it seems to be comparing the battles sanctioned by the Pope during a few centuries against any expansion battle by any Islamic state over a period greater than a millennium. I don't know if this is true or not, but I assume they're referring to the early islamic expansion (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Early_Muslim_conquests https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Early_Muslim_conquests), it's comparing the centuries of the crusade to just ~150 years.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoThanks for articulating that better than I would have (or did, apparently).
- boomboomsubban 8y ago>o compare it to a baseline of something universally regarded as "not peaceful". Assuming you agree that the crusades weren't peaceful then you can't really claim that islamic expansion was peaceful can you? Though I agree that the Crusades were not peaceful, I disagree that they are universally regarded as such. Many people view them as some righteous expulsion of the terrible Muslims, which is why this comparison is an issue. >I don't know if this is true or not, but I assume they're referring to the early islamic expansion Still assuming that the video linked elsewhere is the document, as it matches the description, this is not the case. It may be some other source, but given the difficulty in making anything resembling a fair comparison between the expansions of an empire and pilgrimage invasions, I would guess that source is also pushing a narrative. Why else would you compare all expansion by the Muslims in the 7th century against only a small subset of wars in the 11th? It's entirely possible that you and the poster are unaware of how loaded that argument is, but it's still used to say Islam is necessarily violent and must be removed.
- flukus 8y ago
- BookmarkSaver 8y agoThey may not have been "uniquely" expansionist, but they were easily one of the most expansionist civilizations/empires to ever exist. I take big issue with calling them "devoted to peace". The same as I'd take issue with calling Mongols, Romans, or Alexander's Greeks/Macedonians being called "devoted to peace". They very obviously were not. For selfish reasons, they provoked a staggering level of warfare, on a totally different scale as the typical kingdoms that existed throughout the world.