7 ms·
It's hard to move the line back without getting into "pre-crime" territory but I think there's some room. If someone is inciting generalized violence against a
by sp332 8y ago
It's hard to move the line back without getting into "pre-crime" territory but I think there's some room. If someone is inciting generalized violence against a large group of people, that doesn't meet the current standard for imminent danger. Even after someone else takes up the call and commits a crime, the person who encouraged it might continue without being charged at all. And I'd like to think there's something proactive we can do, instead of trying to get "justice" after the fact while mopping up the blood.
- gnarbarian 8y agoSo based on this reasoning we should be prosecuting antifa quite a bit more vigorously right? Even while intentions remain good, I utterly lack the confidence in our legal system to apply these laws fairly and not selectively. They will always be used by groups with more political clout against their adversaries. Which gets back to my original point.
- kazagistar 8y agoUnless you pick sides morally, trying to potentially incite a revolution certainly seems to classify as hate speech. It just happens to be hate speech directed at an absolute monarchy which has done terrible things to its people, but that's where you get into the far more murky waters of inciting justified violence.
- sp332 8y agoBut if they're making specific threats, that would be illegal even under US law already.
- tomp 8y agoHow can you not pick sides morally if you're using a label such as "hate speech"? After all, that's a moral judgement (although the word itself usually denotes an emotion).
- sp332 8y agoIt's just a label. (And you already contradicted yourself.) Hate speech is speech that encourages discrimination or violence against a group of people based on certain protected categories, e.g. race, religion, gender. So if someone says "no one should hire short people because they can't reach things on tall shelves", that would be fine. If they say "no one should hire Muslims because they take time off to pray each day" that would be hate speech. Categories get added based on past behavior. Disparaging short people is kinda bad, but it wouldn't (even in jurisdictions that ban hate speech) be illegal because there hasn't been a mass campaign of violence and discrimination based on height. On the other hand, divisions between races, religions etc have been pretty damaging so they're on the list.
- tomp 8y agoI disagree with your definition (I don't think it has to do with history, or with a subjectively-chosen list of characteristics). I guess my morality is different, i.e. we're taking sides. But regardless, parent used "hate speech directed at an absolute monarchy" which doesn't fit into any of your categories and is clearly an oppressive abuse of the overall concept. Quite immoral, if you ask me.
- gnarbarian 8y agoSo who gets to decide which groups get protected and which are not protected? And doesn't that immediately demonstrate protected groups have more incidental political power than the groups who are not? It seems to me by definition the groups with the most political clout will be the first to be protected because they were able to get the legislation passed to protect their group!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sp332 8y agoWe already have protected categories defined. You can take issue with the process but it's not a new thing. And no I don't think that when powerful interests have committed eugenics campaigns and taken the vote away from certain groups of people that those groups have more political power. As for how it will go in the future, it's of course possible that it will be abused and there will have to be accountability. But so far it's looking OK and that gives me some hope. It's not like women voted to give themselves the vote, or black people overpowered white people to get schools desegregated etc.
- MaxBarraclough 8y ago> trying to potentially incite a revolution certainly seems to classify as hate speech How's that? Inciting violence can be a crime, but it's not hate speech, it's a different crime. Saying critical things about a political regime can be a crime, in an oppressive country, but again, it's not hate speech. Wikipedia's working definition seems about right: > Hate speech is speech that attacks a person or group on the basis of attributes such as race, religion, ethnic origin, national origin, sex, disability, sexual orientation, or gender identity.
- prolikewh0a 8y ago>trying to potentially incite a revolution certainly seems to classify as hate speech. I don't see this as any type of hate speech, especially if it's a peaceful revolution. If that many people decide to change things peacefully, isnt that just democracy? A hypothetical: Near 100% of non-essential people in jobs just stopping going to work is not really violent and at that point it would likely be police/government getting violent against their own people for not working. A revolution can mean a lot of things.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- specialist 8y ago"...like to think there's something proactive we can do..." Here's a real world example: Bill O'Reilly's hate speech resulting in the murder of Dr George Tiller. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Tiller#Negative_publicity:_The_O'Reilly_Factor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Tiller#Negative_publici... What would you do to prevent this in the future?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sp332 8y agoThat's not really hate speech, but maybe O'Reilly could at least be held accountable after the fact? That might have a deterrent effect anyway.
- specialist 8y agoBeen chewing on this, responding in general, not specifically to you. Thanks for listening. -- A crucial distinction missing from these hate speech slap fights is punching up vs punching down. These conflicts are not symmetrical. Those pretending otherwise stretches incredulity. And credibility. -- I could be persuaded that O'Reilly didn't intend for actual harm be visited upon Dr Tiller. So use whatever labels work best. Like the difference between involuntary manslaughter and premeditated murder. Libel, slander, just being an asshole, whatever. But he's still responsible.