Given Google hasn't laid out any particular solution and they're still being criticized, it seems to me that HN is so cynical of large tech companies exercising

Given Google hasn't laid out any particular solution and they're still being criticized, it seems to me that HN is so cynical of large tech companies exercising their monopoly power (because of past practices) that they're afraid of any effort to rethink the fundamentals of the web. Which on one level makes sense. It's good to protect things that have made the web great. However, it's also good to maintain a spirit of innovation and willingness to question those things that people assume has to work a certain way just because it's always worked that way. When there's a specific proposal, and if that proposal is a bad one, attack it on the merits. But there are real problems of security and user friendliness when it comes to URLs and I don't see anybody else working on it. Does anybody really think that it's impossible to improve and the way we do things now is exactly the way we should be doing it 100 years from now?