2 ms·
> This is off the top of my head. There's lots more. I'm sure there is. But there's no way to pretend that it at all approaches the scale of discrimination tha
by wtallis 8y ago
> This is off the top of my head. There's lots more.
I'm sure there is. But there's no way to pretend that it at all approaches the scale of discrimination that women or blacks or gays have been subjected to. The mere existence of violent reprisals doesn't put their victimization on an equal footing with those who had to fear the KKK. Those events are currently far more exceptional than gay-bashing or lynching of blacks have been in the past.
And among your specific examples, all but Stanger were activists working in support of political causes that put other minorities in a very understandable defensive mood, given how government-supported white nationalism would obviously cause far more harm than white nationalists have been receiving from the riots they help incite. (This is not to say that they were deserving of violence because of their activism, but it means they aren't a representative sample of their political group as a whole.)
The picture I'm seeing isn't tyranny or even a trajectory leading to tyranny. It's outlier events at the fringe of a conflict that is overwhelmingly a peaceful albeit heated political conflict. Any disagreement at this scale will have outliers like this. More than one quarter of US adults voted for Trump. Are there any demographic measures by which they're collectively worse off than blacks during the Jim Crow era? Especially the ones who are no more active in promoting their beliefs than bumper stickers, yard signs, and voting in primaries? Are there actual statistics to support your assertions that they're being thoroughly shut out of so many career paths and industries, not just self-selecting to avoid institutions they view as full of bad people and bad morals? Is anyone who's not a public figure being subjected to this supposed tyranny?
Calling the current conditions for right-wing extremists in the US "tyranny" seems like a vast overreach (and one that offensively minimizes much worse historical oppressions), which is why I asked for clarification whether that was what was really meant.