4 ms·
> Morality systems come on top of this fundamental fact, because morality systems are just the conscious justifications we give to our feelings. This is a seri
by woodruffw 8y ago
> Morality systems come on top of this fundamental fact, because morality systems are just the conscious justifications we give to our feelings.
This is a serious claim, one that moral philosophers (even those inclined towards moral fictionalism/nonrealism) have issues with. Just two of them:
* This account fails to distinguish between moral beliefs and cultural taboos. Individuals tend to think that they can justify both, but challenging taboos is more likely to result in confabulation -- individuals are willing to concede hypothetical concerns in their moral beliefs, but remain committed to their taboos even in the face of good evidence against them.
* Moral philosophy, as it exists today, doesn't seek to provide justification to homophobia, gender discrimination, &c. The dominant metaethical views don't give any consideration at all to these particulars, but rather accept as conclusions (via utilitarian calculus, via a supreme principle, &c) that homophobia and the rest are all morally unjustified. Where does this fit into the pattern matching to feelings to confabulated justifications pipeline?
- DonHopkins 8y agoAt first I thought you wrote "uterine calculus", so I looked it up. That's a thing! TIL that there are a many different kinds of biological calculus. https://medical-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/uterine+calculus https://medical-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/uterine+cal...