4 ms·
The headline is weird - instead of legalising, it should say "decriminalises" in my opinion. Someone made it illegal at some point. The headline now seems to in
by Cthulhu_ 8y ago
The headline is weird - instead of legalising, it should say "decriminalises" in my opinion. Someone made it illegal at some point. The headline now seems to indicate "we've made a new law that allows it", but that makes it like it's an exception.
- rebuilder 8y agoDecriminalization AFAIK is a reducement in criminal penalties while not necessarily making the act in question legal, while legalization is an outright removal of the crime status. I'm not sure whether it makes a difference that this legalization hinges on a new supreme court ruling, not legislative action.
- shkkmo 8y agoNo, "decriminalize" means "reduce or eliminate the penalties/enforcement for a criminal act (but it is still against the law)" while "legalize" means "make a criminal act no longer criminal (it is no longer against the law)". Oddly enough, this means that "criminalize" is not the opposite of "decriminalize" but of "legalize".
- jacobush 8y agoWouldn't that depend entirely if the law was only in criminal law? If so, decriminalize would remove all of the illegality?
- cknight 8y agoCriminal law is not a neat container. A crime is simply anything which is defined as being a criminal act within a given piece of legislation. You can "decriminalise" something either by eliminating the entire piece of legislation, or by amending it to remove the criminal act within it. In the case of the latter, that leaves open the option of replacing it with other words that might indicate civil penalties. If that happens, that is still decriminalisation, and would be distinct from legalisation.
- cknight 8y agoLegalised is more or less correct in this case. Decriminialising something means it could still be illegal, as a civil offense. Importantly, like the US, UK and Australia, India is a "Common Law" nation. That means court rulings set binding legal precedents which can only be overruled by higher courts or actual legislation introduced later. In short: A judgement becomes law. This is opposed to "Civil Law" societies (most of the rest) where court rulings do not set legal precedent, and might only be "persuasive" to other judges in other cases. Plenty of exceptions depending on the country, which court, etc. but that's a general overview. Perhaps for people from Civil Law countries it would be odd to hear that a court has legalised something.