3 ms·
> There is also the issue of the name being disliked and not actually the perceived color of the person. Aversion to unfamiliar ethnic names is entirely differe
by emodendroket 8y ago
> There is also the issue of the name being disliked and not actually the perceived color of the person. Aversion to unfamiliar ethnic names is entirely different than hating black people. While it is will play out poorly for those with such names it does not guarantee that the same person with a different name would have experienced the same callback rate. This is a phenomena that transcends race. This also is probably a good time to point out assimilation is part of living in a mixed race society. If I recall correctly, the notion of black names started sometime after the 1960s. This happened more so in low-income racially divided areas. It was part of Afrocentrism. While there is nothing wrong with that in general, it can have unintended consequences that are not necessarily racially charged. Meanwhile other immigrants had taken on more traditionally American names, as a result those groups seemed to have done very well in the US (Asians). To keep it short, sometimes it does not pay to be unique.
In case you've forgotten, black people were brought to this country against their will and their culture, heritage, and genealogical record was deliberately destroyed. Choosing a black name is a small attempt to reverse that tremendous damage. To turn around and say that if they want to be successful they have to "assimilate" is to me a position that's indefensible. You may also remember that the position of black workers was actually not more equal before the 1960s.
I am also not very reassured to hear that maybe they're merely rejecting people with the wrong class background out of hand.
> But none of that matters, because I never claimed there was no discrimination. But I have repeatedly stated how to solve the problem without using more discrimination. That is to pump money and education efforts into low income areas. More aid to single parent families, access to computers (not just access, but actual computers in their names). Classes on personal finance, and dealing with money. Cultivating a notion of delayed gratification. Paid classes for low income parents to learn more about what they can do to make their child successful. Subsidized match savings accounts that are released in full on graduating high school. And 3 free meals at low income schools. I think it would also be interesting to see how to desegregate low income black schools from low income white schools. Don't forget the teachers! Competitive salaries that can support hiring the best of the teachers for these areas.
All these solutions presume the inferiority of black candidates when we're looking at the reality that identical credentials are less valued from black candidates. The idea that black people are uniquely lacking in "delayed gratification" is also bordering on offensive racist caricature.
It is all well and good to improve the schooling circumstances of black students, but it seems equally important to make it so black candidates do not have to be overwhelmingly superior to even be considered over white ones.
- mbrumlow 8y ago> black people were brought to this country against their will and their culture This is a nice argument for maybe the first few generations, but all of us, you and me and everybody had no choice where we were born even what color we are. People get shuffled and moved around this earth for all sorts of misfortunate reasons. You also have to deal with the fact that there has been voluntary immigration of blacks since slavery. I was just reading how more sub-Saharan immigrants have came to the US since slavery than the entirety of those shipped here by slave traders. Much of the renewed culture has been attributed to those with a choice and fresh connections to Africa. > I am also not very reassured to hear that maybe they're merely rejecting people with the wrong class background out of hand. Nobody said it was good that anybody would do it, but it is entirely different problem that is not racism, and something that is within the power of change. A person can't change his skin color to get a better chance at a job, but a person can change their name. This goes for people of all color born with a name that does not perform as well. A white Harvard grad with the name Butkiss is likely going to have trouble true. The point is discrimination on immutable characteristics is what we are fighting here. > All these solutions presume the inferiority of black candidates when we're looking at the reality that identical credentials are less valued from black candidates. The idea that black people are uniquely lacking in "delayed gratification" is also bordering on offensive racist caricature. Please go read my comment again. My solutions are applied to the poor, not by race, that is my entire point. Fix the poor problem and the race issues described in this thread go away. Why? Because we will have more people educated, including whites that may have grown up to be racist or at least had bias tendencies. Affirmative action is like taking pain killers for a curable problem. Educating the masses and raising the bar for all is the actual cure. I feel you have grossly interpret something from my comments that is totally off basis. The ability to display delayed gratification is one of the biggest indicators of future success in life, and it is something that is probably not taught by the parents of the poor, I know it was not in my household. No assumption about the candidates were being made at all, although many have suggested considering a lower marked minority over a higher marked white person. I don't make derogatory generalization about any group identified by a immutable characteristic. The only sensible thing to do when two candidates who are equally qualified for a position is simply flip a coin. This would remove any bias and over time have a more natural result in what you are attempting to achieve. > It is all well and good to improve the schooling circumstances of black students, but it seems equally important to make it so black candidates do not have to be overwhelmingly superior to even be considered over white ones. Again, I said poor, not black students, poor. I am not concerned with the candidates. Quite simply if a qualified black candidate does not get the job because of his race then that is discrimination and should be dealt with, there are means to do so already in place. I am 100% on board with everybody having an equal opportunity. If you can show that somebody is selecting one candidate over another based on things like color (especially to underrepresented people), then we should be going after them full force and ensuring they correct their hiring processes. You simply can't create a right with two wrongs. Once you give people the power to discriminate it is hard to go back. Nobody should ever not get a job because they had the wrong skin color, and when you say chose somebody based off skin color you are ensuring the number of people who don't get a job because of their skin color goes, not down. We should be striving to remove race based decisions from our society not adding them.