2 ms·
My concern wasn't with speculating that anybody is hiding anything in HPolyC but with the comparable amount of code amongst which naughty things might be hidden
by tialaramex 8y ago
My concern wasn't with speculating that anybody is hiding anything in HPolyC but with the comparable amount of code amongst which naughty things might be hidden, today or in future, in Linux, or more likely, in something else.
Unfortunately HPolyC is _much_ bigger and more complicated. I'm sure it gets Google's job done, but I think overall purging Speck because of people's weird paranoia about the NSA was an unforced error and we'll regret it.
- tptacek 8y agoHPolyC is "bigger" but is built out of cryptographic components you generally already have to trust: the Poly1305 MAC and the XChaCha cipher. It's a construction, not a new block cipher transform. So obviously it takes more lines of code to run it. But it introduces fewer new primitives.